On what basis do you rate a manga/anime to be better than the other?

[grizzlyshree]

On what basis do you rate a manga/anime to be better than the other ? is it by powerlevels?,storyline? pace?screenplay?characterisation?

so in what way do u rate Naruto among the mangas?

 

[Xāvî1]

Story, drama, comedy, and action

 

[-ahhimane-]

If I enjoy the manga/anime then I don't need to rate those things.

 

[foxyladyland]

Story, drama, comedy, and action

that stuff up there ^^^^ and who's copying whose story . carefully thought out oh em gee I cant believe that happened and oh mai gawd moments. Live up to the potential hype and stuff . Also beautiful characters .

Naruto goes down and up all the time , but its good. Should've been a lot better. <.< I still luv it.
Don't copy too much from others and under develop too much .

If I enjoy the manga/anime then I don't need to rate those things.

and this ^^^ I like plenty of anime with no real purpose for even existing other than being pretty cool. :O

 

[kladara]

Characters , story and developments .

 

[grizzlyshree]

that stuff up there ^^^^ and who's copying whose story . carefully thought out oh em gee I cant believe that happened and oh mai gawd moments. Live up to the potential hype and stuff . Also beautiful characters .

Naruto goes down and up all the time , but its good. Should've been a lot better. <.< I still luv it.
Don't copy too much from others and under develop too much .


and this ^^^ I like plenty of anime with no real purpose for even existing other than being pretty cool. :O

yeah i too love such animes but what do you mean by being copied? any examples?

 

[Yo pappy]

Story, art, and characters. Everything else is secondary for me.

 

[xcoyote]

Plot,art,pacing and characterization.

 

[paratise]

Storyline
Characterization
Pace
Art

In this order.

 

[Kurama2012]

if i enjoy the series

 

[Sherlock.]

On the basis of the story,the plot twists and characters.... =D =D

I would have said like "If I enjoy the series" but I realized something after watching Death Note....

For me Death Note > Naruto and FMA but If I have to rewatch episodes of any series frequently then I'd pick Naruto and FMA over Death Note cause it's light hearted....

Death Note even being a Master Piece I cannot watch it more than once or twice a year cause of its too Dark theme.... =D =D