What do you guys think

[SabakuNoGaaraOVZ]

1.He should've stayed true to Itachi's wishes, Itachi killing the clan may have saved sasukes life cuz if there were a coup, other villages could have taken advantage of the mayhem going on from a civil war in konoha, he could've died either way but Itachi wanted to make sure he'd live, so he acting like a **** about his clan, no offense but they were gonna **** too much stuff up, Sasuke needs to realize this and grow the hell up. I'm not saying it'd be easy but sometimes you have to focus on the greater good.

2.He's an even bigger **** for disrespecting his bros dying wish, Itachi sacrificed so much for sasuke and he dashed it to the rocks, squandering the power that Itachi gave him to protect konoha on dreams of revenge, He was really selfish for that one.

I'm asking what he should have done instead, not what he shouldnt

 

[Retsu]

He should've stayed in konoha, and when he found out about Itachi he should've tried his best to carry out his wishes.

 

[Cooh]

He should've stayed in konoha, and when he found out about Itachi he should've tried his best to carry out his wishes.

That would have been some boring stuff lol

 

[Optimistic]

People who dislike him because of how his whole persona changed after his whole clan got wiped out would most likely react 10 times worse than Sasuke.I like Sasuke he keeps the story interesting.

 

[SabakuNoGaaraOVZ]

I feel like those who're saying he shouldnt destroy konoha only say that because they like konoha, or am I wrong?
I mean, he just found out that his people was being discriminated against from the beginning and that his village hid the truth about his family and justified killing them. They couldve stopped Itachi but didnt. Also, the third hokage himself gave Danzo the responsibility to deal with the 'darkness' in the village so basically hes responsible for Danzo's actions as well.

 

[MinatoTheYellowFlash]

Then why is he Kishi's favorite character???

Because he made him, he wouldn't have made him if he didn't like him. Plus his son also made him.

 

[SabakuNoGaaraOVZ]

He should've stayed in konoha, and when he found out about Itachi he should've tried his best to carry out his wishes.

Just like that? like, **** my family, eventhough I got scarred for life and had a f*cked up childhood, its for konoha

 

[SabakuNoGaaraOVZ]

Because he made him, he wouldn't have made him if he didn't like him. Plus his son also made him.

So you think he made him cus he likes him but he didnt want anyone else to like him?
That doesnt make sense

 

[Retsu]

Just like that? like, **** my family, eventhough I got scarred for life and had a f*cked up childhood, its for konoha

if the uchiha would have attempted the coup it would have been open season on konoha, do you know how many ppl would attack konoha knowing they're having a civil war? And sasuke always acts like he's so damn mature, he should know that. The cloud attempted to steal a byakugan before, you think they and any other village wouldn't try and go harvest some sharingan and byakugan during there little civil war?

 

[SabakuNoGaaraOVZ]

if the uchiha would have attempted the coup it would have been open season on konoha, do you know how many ppl would attack konoha knowing they're having a civil war? And sasuke always acts like he's so damn mature, he should know that. The cloud attempted to steal a byakugan before, you think they and any other village wouldn't try and go harvest some sharingan and byakugan during there little civil war?

Dont get me wrong, the war would break out and killing the uchiha was the perfect solution for them, but not for the uchiha and definetly not for Sasuke. Whether it was good or bad for konoha you cant expect him to accept it right? I mean, if i steal your wallet and you find out that i did it and asked me why, and I'd reply with something like; look man, i was really hungry back then and i didnt have money man so I needed that 400$ so im not giving it back. Would you be like..hmmm well thats fine then never mind bye?

 

[Retsu]

Dont get me wrong, the war would break out and killing the uchiha was the perfect solution for them, but not for the uchiha and definetly not for Sasuke. Whether it was good or bad for konoha you cant expect him to accept it right? I mean, if i steal your wallet and you find out that i did it and asked me why, and I'd reply with something like; look man, i was really hungry back then and i didnt have money man so I needed that 400$ so im not giving it back. Would you be like..hmmm well thats fine then never mind bye?

sasuke needs to realize he'd more than likely be dead had Itachi not carried out his orders, and once again, I know it wouldn't be easy, but if my family members blatantly break the law I don't stick by them, you've messed up at that point and if you bring harm down upon yourself as a result of your negative behaviour and participation in dubious activities, that is your fault.

 

[Raekwon26]

He reacted perfectly both times.
I would have reacted 10 times as worse. Konoha wouldn't be standing right now if it was me.

 

[Crossroads]

I'd like Sasuke's character more if he didn't have fapboy's left and right D riding him.

OP: Sasuke is a decent character, he had good reason to act the way he did up until finding out the truth about Itachi.

 

[SabakuNoGaaraOVZ]

sasuke needs to realize he'd more than likely be dead had Itachi not carried out his orders, and once again, I know it wouldn't be easy, but if my family members blatantly break the law I don't stick by them, you've messed up at that point and if you bring harm down upon yourself as a result of your negative behaviour and participation in dubious activities, that is your fault.

Are you saying the uchiha were wrong for planning a coup? It wasnt a smart move, but they were being discriminated against by tobirama, he started it. And sasuke doesnt have to be that grateful to Itachi, he couldve been as dead as he couldve been alive. Itachi has witnessed war at a younger age and survived it. And when the sand attacked most survived as well. Also, Itachi did spare Sasuke, but he decided for Sasuke to have such a f*cked up life so he doesnt really have to do whatever Itachi wanted to do in life. Its not like his family got the death penalty, its more like they got assassinated by the government..

He reacted perfectly both times.
I would have reacted 10 times as worse. Konoha wouldn't be standing right now if it was me.

Same here, i would awaken me some rinnegan eyes and tengai shinsei that village with the uchiha logo on the meteorites

 

[Hawker Fury]

Well, With Sasuke I have liked his character and disliked him depending on the situation. The only character I can claim to hate in Naruto is Obito for being an irritating none entity and for the ruthless murder of the charming character called Tobi (who actually had a personality)

First we do have to remember that Sasuke did not know anything about why Itachi killed everybody until somebody told him about it (quite a while after the event)

Therefor this revelation crushed his previous understanding of his brother as a murdering lunatic (which I think Itachi still was anyway… he did kill his parents, his extended family, friends and his entire community after all. No matter for what reasons anybody who would do all that is still rather deranged)

So from shifting his blame from his brother who he had just killed (or assisted in his suicide) he was informed by Mr. unknown Uchiha that a Konoha conspiracy was responsible for his brother’s actions (well, I still think Itachi was responsible for those actions no matter who gave the order, his choice)

Now, even if the list of people responsible for the order can be limited to a few names it was the village structure which issued those orders and Itachi’s dedication to that cause which was responsible for the murder. Sasuke could have been enraged at his brother’s dedication to the village and therefore hated the village as strongly he hated Itachi. In effect the vengeance he had delivered against Itachi upon the implication of Konoha in the act could not be left to rest in peace and instead shifted fully to ending what had become a matter unfinished.

I would criticize Sasuke for so readily “forgiving” Itachi at this point but I think his hatred to the village structure which had cost him his family is entirely justified.

I think Sasuke abandoned his plans of vengeance far to easily after his talk with the Hokage. I am considering if Sasuke may have not changed his mind and has ether decided to remove the immediate threat (Obito and Madara who would take away his opportunity to avenge himself against the leaf) and then attack the leaf. Or if he has focused his vendetta at the village’s high command and desires the position of Hokage so that he may purge them out (the elders, black ops and all those chaps)

I liked Sasuke’s character especially during his argument with Naruto before leaving the village and his self conflict over the choice of staying or leaving. Since then however I have felt that character’s personality has been influenced too heavily by the needs of the plot then his character development. What I mean is that many decisions Sasuke has taken seem forced, unreal. Some of them have been legitimate although not so thoroughly worked out but some such as the most recent return to the “light side” does feel forced. I do hope there is more to this decision then meets the eye however I am afraid to say I do not have enough faith in Kishi to make such a plot twist.

Sasuke cannot be expected to carry out actions just because his big brother told him so, he is his own person. I think disliking Sasuke just because of his naughty actions is a denial of his history, any one after being though what he has been though would have some… problems.

In some way’s Sasuke’s life is even more traumatic then Gara’s and look what a pleasant little runt Gara was when he was a kid!

 

[Neonian]

Not cause hes emo lol

 

[EternalFlame]

It's fine. He reacted realistic on both in my opinion.

I'd be far worse but then again it's somewhat ignorant of me to say that since I don't know what it's like to have everything in the world, and then to lose it all in one night by your seemingly loving older brothers hand all at the age of 7.

I don't know what it's like to see an entire clan dead, corpses everywhere, including your own parents. I don't know what it's like to be tortured mentally and to relive the act over and over until driven to madness. I don't know what it's like to be manipulated and brainwashed into believing revenge is all that matters, frightened to make friends out of fear of losing everything again.

And then if it wasn't bad already, it takes a turn far worse when he found out that the village he was born in, his village was responsible for the murder of his entire clan. It was all a lie, Sasuke devoted years trying to kill Itachi all on a lie.

 

[Naijakid]

Hes a villain. If i started to like a villain, then Kishimoto can't write a good villain.

As brilliant as ever