[Discussion] Uzumaki => Red Haired, but Red Haired => Uzumaki?

[Mr Hiru]

(Some people may find this on other thread, but I felt to make it clear).

---

The red hair is a trait from the Uzumaki Clan... really? Well, if this was really the case (just the red hair as a dogma and that's all) then Gaara should be Uzumaki (his father's hair was kinda red too), Sasori should be Uzumaki (his father's hair was kinda red too), and even Sakura should be Uzumaki (she has pink hair, but her mother has blond hair and his father has red hair).

Let me show you something interesting...

Nagato (Younger):

You must be registered for see images

Sasori and his Father (both younger) :

You must be registered for see images

Sasori (20 Years passed):

You must be registered for see images

Haruno Kizashi (Younger):

You must be registered for see images

Haruno Kizashi (Older):

You must be registered for see images

Gaara (Young):

You must be registered for see images

Gaara's Father (Fourth Kazekage, the one in the right... not pure red-haired):

You must be registered for see images

Now people, do you think that the Red Hair is a trait unique to the Uzumaki Clan? Or maybe is more correct to assume that the Red Hair is a common trait among the members of this clan, but not unique among clans?

I believe that it's the second, because if all the mentioned characters were Uzumaki, then Sakura should have enormous chakra pool... and Kakashi already stated the contrary.

 

[~Naruto&Itachi~]

And Shikamaru is uchiha??

 

[foxyladyland]

that was beautiful and whatnot like their hair.
and Sakura's mom almost look like her English Dubbed Voice Actress.. she's beautiful..
samui the angelbeam is hawt too though

You must be registered for see images

[video=youtube;U4NtPTTAwBo]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U4NtPTTAwBo[/video]

 

[reizon]

whats with that haruno guy's sidelocks..??

 

[Mr Hiru]

And Shikamaru is uchiha??

That's the thing, the argument of "Red hair = Uzumaki" doesn't convince me at all I believe this trait is common in pure-breed Uzumaki members, but it's not unique in the world... I believe there are persons out there that have red hair and they are not Uzumaki (not even related).

 

[NOemotions]

Obito said something about uzumaki clan trademark = red hair to nagato.. but it's foolishness to think that every uzumaki has red hair xd Only i know for sure most of them has very sick chakra reserves..

 

[fahadkurama]

Because Naruto is half Uzumaki

 

[Mr Hiru]

Now somebody gets it.

But Sakura's father has Red hair... then explain why Sakura doesn't have high chakra pools, or at least mid chakra pools.

Even if you tell in MY thread that you have a theory that is 10 times better, I just found a contradiction that dismantles YOUR theory...

GG

 

[TrueRage]

Nagato is an Uzumaki and was said in the manga

 

[Mr Hiru]

Funny, you did not even read mine.

I did, and you still can't explain my point ...

PS: Stop spamming in my thread.

Nagato is an Uzumaki and was said in the manga

And because Nagato was explicitely said an Uzumaki, he is an Uzumaki.

My point is other... I'm saying that not all red-hair people are Uzumaki.

 

[itachi732]

But Sakura's father has Red hair... then explain why Sakura doesn't have high chakra pools, or at least mid chakra pools.

Even if you tell in MY thread that you have a theory that is 10 times better, I just found a contradiction that dismantles YOUR theory...

GG

"Genes do change over the years, decades and longer with family trees expanding and creation of clans. That explains why some families and clans do have red hair. Not all families have red hair though of course. Consider Uzumaki, Naruto for example. He is the son of Minato and Uzumaki, Kushina. Naruto does not have red hair because he is half Uzumaki and his dads features were the dominate genes, and somehow he had his moms personality, in mind by Kishimoto for a compelling character. So to point out that, when families are expanding and new clans are being created for the next generation, the red hair would obviously disappear in do time. Combining of clans over the years changed the appearance of older and died out clans. That is why there is rarely any red haired characters running through Naruto. They are dying out."

-NeonStormTV™/Itachi732 Theory-

 

[Mr Hiru]

Your damn thread has no true motive in describing how Sakura is also related. Fool, if you did read it carefully, I damn well explain that clans do degenerate.

Sakura's father has red hair, almost the same color as Nagato, who was declared as an Uzumaki.

Your thread explains the degeneration of genes, so the red hair could turn into a recesive gen with the presence of other dominant genes (the case of Naruto inheriting his father blonde hair), but the case of chakra pool is slighty different. Why? If Sakura's father was an Uzumaki, there is no way Sakura inherited incredibly low chakra pools. With degeneration of genes, she had to inherit at least mid to high levels of chakra (Uzumaki has outstanding levels of chakra), and let's be honest... the Uzushiogakure didn't dissapear long time ago, so there is no way these genes could degenerate that much for starters.

This said, your thread doesn't have enough basis... there haven't passed more than 30 years in Narutoverse since the destruction of Uzushiogakure, that leaves the possibility of degeneration of genes opened for only 1 degenerated generation (as much).

PS: I would appreciate lowering your tone, I'm not lacking respect here... keep that arrogant and unrespectful attitude and I'll take another courses of actions. Understood?

 

[Everztar]

Majority of the Uzumaki had red hair... there will always be other people with the same haircolor? and there will be hybrids... like Naruto

 

[Your Creepy Stalker]

SOMEONE HAS RED HAIR! THEY MUST BE AN UZUMAKI.

That is typical logic here. For a start, its strait red hair, even when naruto imagined himself with red hair, it was strait. Nuff said.

 

[Mr Hiru]

Majority of the Uzumaki had red hair... there will always be other people with the same haircolor? and there will be hybrids... like Naruto

Sakura inherited low chakra pool, but his father had red-hair, so the logic of Red-Hair = Uzumaki fails hard here. That lends me to believe that there are people on Narutoverse with red hair and are not related of the Uzumaki.

 

[H a n]

I see what you are getting at.