Film or Anime?

[Chakra Wizard]

My main career goal right now is to write scripts for films, but there are a ton of ideas I have that, if I can somehow get into the anime industry, I would like to see made one day. Right now, though, I'm kinda conflicted in regards to what would be the proper medium for some of my ideas. If anyone would be willing to help me decide whether any of these premises would be better served portrayed as a live-action film or an animated...anime (lol), I'd greatly appreciate it, cause I've almost given up hope on deciding for myself.

I'm not posting them all here - one, because there's a lot of them, and two, because I wouldn't want anyone taking one of them for their own use - and this is just to see who is willing to help me out. In addition to your "vote", I'd also appreciate it if you let me know what factors would make it better suited for a film or an anime, just some reasoning to back up your decision, really. Those who say "yes", I'll gladly PM you one of my premises for you to judge, maybe more of them if I like your feedback

Also, I suppose it's important to note that all of these ideas I'm conflicted on are potential films right now. It's not too hard for me to tell when something should be an anime. These are basically just ideas that started as films that I'm beginning to have second thoughts on, just to kinda clear the air.

Thanks in advance to those who decide to help

 

[Germanicus]

Send me your ideas dude. It would depend on the idea for whether film or anime is better. I personally enjoy film more, but let's see what you got.

 

[Chakra Wizard]

Send me your ideas dude. It would depend on the idea for whether film or anime is better. I personally enjoy film more, but let's see what you got.

Thanks a lot, man=D

And yeah, but there's also that common belief that anime has no bounds, and there are certain important aspects in most of my ideas that make me unsure that live-action is really the best medium. That's why I'm reconsidering the decision to make films out of them.

 

[Moss]

Much more of a market in film.

 

[Chakra Wizard]

Much more of a market in film.

True, but like any artist, I'd rather my work be as perfect as possible, so if it takes animation to pull that off, I'm all for it

 

[Sophie Ezra]

I dont know if i would be much help but i am all for giving an opinion

 

[Chakra Wizard]

I dont know if i would be much help but i am all for giving an opinion

Well, that's all I'm looking for, really, so yeah, absolutely=D I'll go ahead and PM one of them to you now