- Joined
- Aug 16, 2010
- Messages
- 5,276
- Reaction score
- 418
True, we don't know if Minato would have been able to access KCM whilst he was alive, since we never saw him do so. Nonetheless, it wouldn't matter since he's formidable enough with FTG alone.
Learn the difference between fanboy and fan. <(-.-<) I am an Itachi fan, yet I know the limitations of my favourite character. Minato fans are the same, T Bogard in certain cases has displayed this. Minato and Itachi fanboys are both morons in their departments.
Well most Itachi fans I met all wank him to no end. He is the first I have seen to not wank him.Exactly, I hate idiots who throw out "fanboy". I used to always get called one just because I had an Itachi sig, status, avatar and more. It's stupid.
Exactly, I hate idiots who throw out "fanboy". I used to always get called one just because I had an Itachi sig, status, avatar and more. It's stupid.
Tee hee !!i dont see why it doesn't count, edo tensei is pretty much a Resurrection jutsu that makes the person immortal and the only reason people disregard it is because minato was brought back through edo tensei
but lets say minato was brought back through the rinnegan or chiyos jutsu, minato would still be able to use kcm and he would be alive and a user of kcm and its not like edo tensei gives minato the kcm ability so i say it counts
and a verse thread is entirely theoretical to begin with so it all depends on the persons rules that they set and the whole you take a character from their prime is entirely a fan made rule
i dont see why it doesn't count, edo tensei is pretty much a Resurrection jutsu that makes the person immortal and the only reason people disregard it is because minato was brought back through edo tensei
but lets say minato was brought back through the rinnegan or chiyos jutsu, minato would still be able to use kcm and he would be alive and a user of kcm and its not like edo tensei gives minato the kcm ability so i say it counts
and a verse thread is entirely theoretical to begin with so it all depends on the persons rules that they set and the whole you take a character from their prime is entirely a fan made rule
No. Deal with it, and move on. This is why people specify whether they mean Edo or not, there is a massive difference.
actually there isnt that much of a difference, minato was brought back through edo tensei and he shown the ability to use kcm
A VS thread may be theoritical, still doesn't give people the right to say false thing to prove something. You say if Minato was brought back with Rinne Tensei but that's not the point, he wasn't. So technically he's still dead. There is only the alive Minato pre -Naruto and the current Edo Minato.
but minatos ability to use kcm is not false and it is not granted to him by any other means then his own sealing jutsu and i dont think its right that you take kcm away from minato because he was brought back by edo tensei instead of any other method of ressurection
You're honestly arguing with idiots bro lol. They lack common sense to comprehend any of this.
Didn't read anything past this point in your quote, because it is irrelevant. Edo's have unlimited chakra and must be sealed, they cannot die. That is a HUGE difference to a normal state. <(-.-<) Minato used a jutsu which KILLS the user, in order to obtain that chakra. Minato was dead as soon as he casted reaper death seal, regardless of what he did with it.
this doesnt matter in the end of the day you take two shinobi from different times and pit them together in a theoretical situation that could pretty much never happen so minato should have access to kcm and it doesnt matter if minato was due to die moments after as he still gained that power
but minatos ability to use kcm is not false and it is not granted to him by any other means then his own sealing jutsu and i dont think its right that you take kcm away from minato because he was brought back by edo tensei instead of any other method of ressurection
I'm not taking anything from him. An Edo Minato has KCM but a living Minato doesn't. The moment he used Dead Reaper Seal, he was practically dead. And don't let me begin with the fact that he had Kurama's chakra for less than 5 minutes. So no, a living Minato doesn't have KCM.
You're honestly arguing with idiots bro lol. They lack common sense to comprehend any of this.
:sy: When we pit shinobi against each other we do not give them powers they did not have when they were alive, unless they only have access to them when they're EDO. I say it again. Minato technically died the moment he used reaper death seal, and nothing you say can change that. It is an established fact. :sy: