Why kishi doesn't do sakura juctice

Status
Not open for further replies.

DeadManWonderLand

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 2, 2012
Messages
7,167
Reaction score
712
Sakura got some character development finally in today's chapter.

I have pointed out quite a few flaw in her character over quite some time.
It was never out of hate of sakura,that is just a waste of energy and try to make sure i distance myself from the blatant trolls.

I however could not help but see why this sudden development works against her favor.
Now hear me out its not anything against her but,kishi himself.

I think we can all agree that this last chapter was most likely a way to try and make her relevant again.

What is my problem with it then ? Ill tell you.

She has to store chakra up for three years.Or she has been storing it up for three years either way during this battle critical battle she has not helped naruto one single time until recently.

Why didn't kishi have her use this poewrful technique when she had the kurama cloak ?

Kakashi stated its at least 3 times stronger then normal chakra.

Think about the devastating effects of her yin seal if she used it with her cloak given to her by naruto.


The only excuse i can see being given is that the cloak decreased the waiting period for her yin seal to the point she could now use it effectively.However until this is pointed out it,the awful truth is sakura had a chance to really help naruto out
(I don't mean to say she would of tanked obito,but her strength could of offered help)

And if your saying well she is a medic then your also saying she didn't bother to come help until sasuke was there.

Either way kishi has created a very flimsy scenario where he decided to give her that power at the last second or he intentionally had her do nothing when her power would of been outrageously over the top.




He could of use that yin seal with the cloak to give sakura some exclusive panel time by stalling the juubi or obito and letting naruto regenerate chakra.

But like always sakura is never in the spot light and is always thought about last.

Hopefully she has a dire stake in this battle by at least saving naruto or sasuke from a deadly attack.I really,really do
 

Imperfect

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
9,889
Reaction score
950
I think she was waiting until the opportune moment to use it, so she could be more useful and so she could fight alongside Naruto, and Sasuke when he showed up.
 

Zetsueno

Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2013
Messages
457
Reaction score
44
I made a thread trying to point out these flaws in Sakura as well. Although some people here are Sheldon Coopers, so you know, I kinda got trolled. Maybe, you'd want to take a look at it?
 

FourthLegacy

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 14, 2013
Messages
1,217
Reaction score
190
I agree.
But if he did it when the cloak was there, people would think that she couldn't do it on her own. That she needed help from Naruto.
 

sealingscroll

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Aug 17, 2012
Messages
1,067
Reaction score
86
1) he was defending everyone with the kurama cloak half the time
2) while defending while we got a history lesson by hashirama they were defending. Stalling for reinforcements.
3) it has to be Her Chakra not anyone else Chakra inputting into the seal so it wouldn't have done much

She has to store chakra up for three years.Or she has been storing it up for three years either way during this battle critical battle she has not helped naruto one single time until recently.

4)never stated she had to store it up for 3 years to use it, she chose not to use it till her full power was ready. she could have used it at any time i believe.

5) tsunade told her in this chapter a medic ninja is not suppose to die. meaning your idea she should have went all boss a couple of chapters were deflated by tsunades words.

its only a last resort and this is a last resort before the juubi becomes full power.
 

phylos

Leaf Village Regular 🍃
Regular
Joined
May 7, 2013
Messages
579
Reaction score
31
... Nope, still not as bad as the Itachi vs Minato threads but it is getting closer to that point.
 

Zetsueno

Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2013
Messages
457
Reaction score
44
1) he was defending everyone with the kurama cloak half the time
2) while defending while we got a history lesson by hashirama they were defending. Stalling for reinforcements.
3) it has to be Her Chakra not anyone else Chakra inputting into the seal so it wouldn't have done much

She has to store chakra up for three years.Or she has been storing it up for three years either way during this battle critical battle she has not helped naruto one single time until recently.

4)never stated she had to store it up for 3 years to use it, she chose not to use it till her full power was ready. she could have used it at any time i believe.

5) tsunade told her in this chapter a medic ninja is not suppose to die. meaning your idea she should have went all boss a couple of chapters were deflated by tsunades words.

its only a last resort and this is a last resort before the juubi becomes full power.

And the miraculous perceptive abilities foresaw that the hokages will come and hold off the Juubi so they will have a free shot. I agree completely, Sakura is the most perceptive character in the series till now, even more so that Minato and Madara and Obito and even Itachi.
 

staticdash22

Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2012
Messages
440
Reaction score
69
I think she was waiting until the opportune moment to use it, so she could be more useful and so she could fight alongside Naruto, and Sasuke when he showed up.

That's what makes it so bad. It came out of nowhere. As a writer, you don't do stuff like that..period. It makes the fans think this was something you thought up overnight. You expect people to actually believe that sakura has been saving energy in that one spot for 3 whole years? Even during a serious situation like when Pain attacked the village? She didn't feel the need to unleash some of that power to help naruto? That really makes me question her motives. You expect me to believe that she saved her energy just for this moment? It just so happens that now is the most convenient time for her to unleash her true power? Contrived. This continues to expose kishimoto's writing. How did he get to such a place......such a shame that an esteemed writer is making noob mistakes.
 

sealingscroll

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Aug 17, 2012
Messages
1,067
Reaction score
86
plus if anything:

Obito: "naruto, do you love sakura"
Naruto: "i still sorta do"
Obito: "say goodbye to her"
Naruto: "why should i say goodbye"
Obito: "cause she will die" *kamui's sakura into the other dimension kills her brings her back*

Everyone: "OMG SAKURA"
Obito: "i told you i would do it"

there. thats where the whole she should have used it then theory goes into the flames before sasuke and everyone shows up.
 

DeadManWonderLand

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 2, 2012
Messages
7,167
Reaction score
712
1) he was defending everyone with the kurama cloak half the time
2) while defending while we got a history lesson by hashirama they were defending. Stalling for reinforcements.
3) it has to be Her Chakra not anyone else Chakra inputting into the seal so it wouldn't have done much

She has to store chakra up for three years.Or she has been storing it up for three years either way during this battle critical battle she has not helped naruto one single time until recently.

4)never stated she had to store it up for 3 years to use it, she chose not to use it till her full power was ready. she could have used it at any time i believe.

5) tsunade told her in this chapter a medic ninja is not suppose to die. meaning your idea she should have went all boss a couple of chapters were deflated by tsunades words.

its only a last resort and this is a last resort before the juubi becomes full power.

1 & 2 is irrelevant to what i am talking about and your third response is just flat out false naruto specifically changed every chakra portion he gave out to match the person it went into so they could utilize as they saw fit.

And being a master a chakra control would of gave her a perfect chance to use it her justu to the fullest.

This is not about sakura but,more about how kishi and his unwillingness to treat sakura like the main character she supposedly is
 

DeadManWonderLand

Sannin of the Scrolls 📜
Elite
Joined
Jul 2, 2012
Messages
7,167
Reaction score
712
That's what makes it so bad. It came out of nowhere. As a writer, you don't do stuff like that..period. It makes the fans think this was something you thought up overnight. You expect people to actually believe that sakura has been saving energy in that one spot for 3 whole years? Even during a serious situation like when Pain attacked the village? She didn't feel the need to unleash some of that power to help naruto? That really makes me question her motives. You expect me to believe that she saved her energy just for this moment? It just so happens that now is the most convenient time for her to unleash her true power? Contrived. This continues to expose kishimoto's writing. How did he get to such a place......such a shame that an esteemed writer is making noob mistakes.



I am glad you see how this recent development just makes the story look more sloppy,it makes her look like even more of a ***** which will fuel even more sakura hate threads.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top