[Discussion] Why do people try and apply logic into Shounen Manga such as Naruto?

[dvmaz]

Applying logic to Naruto is pointless in its self.

Does anyone have a reason as to why they try to apply logic to fiction?

 

[tenten fan]

Asshats. Only answer.

 

[Bieber]

By applying logic they mean Manga Facts.
If it isn't said in the manga itself, it isn't true.

 

[FreakensteinAG]

Applying logic to Naruto is pointless in its self.

Does anyone have a reason as to why they try to apply logic to fiction?

When is it ever pointless? Logic is what advances the human mind when applied correctly. Any small change in human behavior amplifies our success in the universe.

By applying logic they mean Manga Facts.
If it isn't said in the manga itself, it isn't true.

While it's true that manga facts trump hypotheses, what the manga shows may be interpreted in different ways or isn't explained fully, which calls upon the need for hypothetical means to know what's occurring in the Naruto world.

 

[Sage OfThe 6 Paths]

to explain the unexplainable for example : How the f*ck is he walking on water ? Probably because the buoyancy force of the water ..... no stfu its because he is a f*cking NINJA b*tches F*CK LOGIC

 

[LordHokage22]

manga logic basically what makes the manga unique

 

[Forget Me Not]

I've honestly stopped taking this manga seriously several months ago. Don't know about others.

 

[sepfiroth]

they have time to waste

 

[hugsandkissesnojutsu]

I think it is impossible not to apply logic to Naruto. "Logic" is any particular mode of reasoning. We attempt to reason, make sense of, categorize, understand, comprehend, figure out, and know whats going on. Logic gives us labels for the unknown, so we can make sense of it. If you have an understanding of Naruto, such as it being a "Shounen Manga" this is your own Logic- even if it is a seemingly universal label.

The story of Naruto delves into this aspect of human nature. Characters are all trying to figure out how to REALLY know each other, to live in harmony, etc. Can we TRULY know each other NOT LOGICALLY (not to be confused with illogically), despite the NECESSARY requirement to label and understand each other intellectually?

 

[saw2097]

Its called manga logic, very different from standard logic.

Hard to use though as the author can change the rules anytime he wants.

 

[MrDuck]

They want to feel smarter by criticizing a manga on the internet.