Debate EJBlack Vs Gakido

[pateuvasiliu]

You are showing how they are flawed by your point of the argument and not what Gakido has pointed out in our argument. Show me where the are flaws are through what BOTH of us has brought up/rebuttal.

Then we have different concepts of what a judge should do, then.

As a judge, I usually point out both -BASE-, perhaps unnoticed errors a debater commits as well as discussing the arguments that were brought by the other debater.

I simply decided that you made too many assumptions, even though your opponent might have not noticed them.

It's just my opinion, and come to think of it, it's what I was brought here for.

 

[Brother Numpsay]

Then we have different concepts of what a judge should do, then.

As a judge, I usually point out both -BASE-, perhaps unnoticed errors a debater commits as well as discussing the arguments that were brought by the other debater.

I simply decided that you made too many assumptions, even though your opponent might have not noticed them.

It's just my opinion, and come to think of it, it's what I was brought here for.

You said yourself you look at both contedtant and yet only mention my post. You also admit with your post that the arguments has to fit your views. Since you already view madara as the winner you are putting yiur input that revolving that. That is why to opionions are xlashing between the debater and the judge. So your juding premises is wrong