All Hokages except Tobirama were a failure

[Cromatic]

Tobirama was the only one who knew what he was doing, he made divisions, made village system, made people aware of the facts about Uchiha Clan and even saved Hiruzen and Danzo from dying, who later on became the ones protecting the village.


Hashirama - Failed because he didn't know he was making lots of mistakes, fell under the genjutsu of Madara, and thought he killed him, should have killed Madara right when Tobirama had told him so, eventually Itachi had to kill them all and take that burden.

Hiruzen - Did alot for the clans, and managed to protect Leaf Village from all troubles. Failed because he chose Minato as the next Hokage over Lord Orochimaru.

Minato - LOL , what a joke he was, left his two students to die(one however saved by Madara), couldn't save his wife, placed a very big burden on Naruto by sealing Kurama inside him. He was the biggest failure.
I think Lord Orochimaru and Danzo should have been next Hokage if Hiruzen wanted to retire. Not Minato.
If however he wanted to make someone Intelligent as Hokage, Shikamaru's Father would have been the best choice.


So Tobirama is the only one we can say who kept the village in peace.

Opinions?

 

[avenged sevenfold]

I think your being a bit harsh to be fair. The hokages did their best and did what they thought was best

 

[Hell Autarch]

The only part I liked was the Minato one.

 

[Sefirosu Masamune]

Nope Tobirama failed too. Starting the uchiha police force=bad blood with uchiha.

 

[Orochimaruofthesound]

LOL what have i started

 

[Imperfect]

The village is still intact despite several attempts to destroy it. If that's a failure then victories for you must be few and far between.

 

[-immortal-]

no everyone was equal so said

 

[Insidious Smile]

You must be registered for see images

 

[Prestonyoko]

Didn't the 2nd Hokage invent the jutsu that has been used in 2 great ninja wars and has caused so many ninja to die?

 

[warlee]

He also couldn't solve the uchiha/senju issue he fail just like the others.

 

[Hell Autarch]

I find it wierd how the 4 Hokage have been given so much importance and everyone believe Hashirama, Tobirama, Hiruzen and Minato can stop Madara. I mean the 2nd Tsuchikage, 2nd Mizukage, 4th Kazekage and 3rd Raikage were so easily sealed by the Allied Shinobi

 

[Cromatic]

Nope Tobirama failed too. Starting the uchiha police force=bad blood with uchiha.

Well, it was for the village's peace anyway, and it all went against him because of Uchiha's Own greed, Tobirama was right to tell Hashirama to kill Madara and end this. But it was Hashirama's failure, not Tobirama.

 

[Cromatic]

Didn't the 2nd Hokage invent the jutsu that has been used in 2 great ninja wars and has caused so many ninja to die?

No one knew about that jutsu apart from Lord Orochimaru, had Hiruzen made Orochimaru the Hokage, those jutsu wouldn't have been used against the village. That is another failure of Hiruzen and Minato.

 

[marksonm]

Tobirama also failed, he sealed Izuna's fate and caused Madara to go H.A.M and evil... he allowed his hate for Madara consume him and hence made him push the Uchiha to the outskirts of the village, making them feel unwanted... That's the reason why they planned the coup d'etat in the first place. Tell me what failure is then, if that is not failure

Hashirama was soft yes, but if Madara had not defaulted on their friendship or if Madara was 2nd Hokage as well like how Hiruzen and Minato were Hokages atm then he might have been loyal and Hashirama would have succeeded.

Minato did all that he could, and as a shinobi, he was willing to make alot of sacrifices to save the village from his terrorist student who went rogue thanks to Madara again spoiling his good nature with the evil that he gained from Tobirama's hatred towards him. He sealed the ( tails in his own son because he knew Naruto will need it as his son to beat the evil in the world, which has proven to be the best thing that has happened to Konoha and the Shinobi world to date

Hiruzen tried his best, and btw he couldn't have made orochimaru the next hokage because he lost his way after he lost his parents. Instead I think Jiraya would have made a nice Hokage more than Orochimaru.

 

[IKSOKRIPS]

Didn't the 2nd Hokage invent the jutsu that has been used in 2 great ninja wars and has caused so many ninja to die?

What two Ninja Wars?! hmm

Tobirama also failed, he sealed Izuna's fate and caused Madara to go H.A.M and evil... he allowed his hate for Madara consume him and hence made him push the Uchiha to the outskirts of the village, making them feel unwanted... That's the reason why they planned the coup d'etat in the first place. Tell me what failure is then, if that is not failure

Tobirama failed, because he killed Izuna? Dafuq?! :erm:

 

[maxwellwilson02]

No one knew about that jutsu apart from Lord Orochimaru, had Hiruzen made Orochimaru the Hokage, those jutsu wouldn't have been used against the village. That is another failure of Hiruzen and Minato.

So elect a crazy psycho as your leader? someone who experiments on little boys? not just one but many....like really? how can people really believe orochimaru should be Hokage....If a convicted pedophile who kidnaps little kids and experiments on their body ran for president would you vote for them?

 

[kristofer 8]

Tobirama I think was the most successful because most of what he did helped establish the entire Shinobi world as a whole. The development of the chunin exams, the ninjas academy, and the anbu black ops would later be adopted by the rest of the ninjas world. The development of the uchiha military force can be seen as both bad and good. We say it's bad but at the time it could have been good and strengthened the bond between senju and uchiha because it was an elite position that gave the uchiha authority over the rest of the military. It wasn't until later that it turned bad when the uchiha, like oro said, became arrogant.

 

[wildstorm]

I agree with hashirama thing...
but hiruzen, he was right about decision about 4th hokage.....I think you dont read chapters properly...go & read them again if you want the answer....
lastly, about minato, no one else would've been able to deal with that incident in a better way than him.....although I've always believed that kishi failed in the plot here.....he killed both kushina & minato, to show how they cared about naruto, & all that, but they had an option of saving one of them.......kishi should've thought of a better plot to kill minato....

 

[Stark]

You're being too harsh..

 

[Cromatic]

So elect a crazy psycho as your leader? someone who experiments on little boys? not just one but many....like really? how can people really believe orochimaru should be Hokage....If a convicted pedophile who kidnaps little kids and experiments on their body ran for president would you vote for them?

Maybe.. What are you views about Shikamaru's father then? Gifted Strategist, he could have used Minato and Hiruzen in a better way to defeat Kurama instead of sacrificing Kushina