Rinnegan Confusion

[Shalev]

Why did obito say, when he picked up the rinnegan from Nagato, these eyes were mine to begin with?

Those eyes were Madara's right? Or was it Obito's to begin with?
Obito was able to unlock the rinnegan, without reaching old age? (for he has Hashirama's cell! Yes! makes sense!)

Obito officially unlocked the rinnegan by himself?
So who lended the rinnegan to Nagato? (Madara or Obito?)

Did Madara, before dying, did Madara developed another rinnegan, to be handed down to Obito?

So, does Madara or Obito have a massive supply of rinnegans? (explaining the distributions to the jinchuurikis! each having a rinnegan and sharingan!?)

Pretty cool stuff~

Plot hole is in ...

 

[Vitvol]

I just assumed it was because he was pretending to be Madara.

 

[DrProof]

He was playing the role of Madara. We didn't know who he really was at that point in time.

 

[Shalev]

I just assumed it was because he was pretending to be Madara.

No! that wouldn't makes sense, he was talking to a corpse/ dead person!

 

[Shalev]

I just assumed it was because he was pretending to be Madara.

What's there to pretend, what's the point!
He was talking to a dead body?
What? "No one is here, but I'll still pretend to be Madara?" (that would be foolish)

 

[TheKBD]

Why did obito say, when he picked up the rinnegan from Nagato, these eyes were mine to begin with?

Those eyes were Madara's right? Or was it Obito's to begin with?
Obito was able to unlock the rinnegan, without reaching old age? (for he has Hashirama's cell! Yes! makes sense!)

Obito officially unlocked the rinnegan by himself?
So who lended the rinnegan to Nagato? (Madara or Obito?)

Did Madara, before dying, did Madara developed another rinnegan, to be handed down to Obito?

So, does Madara or Obito have a massive supply of rinnegans? (explaining the distributions to the jinchuurikis! each having a rinnegan and sharingan!?)

Pretty cool stuff~

Plot hole is in ...

well we don't really know for sure if one can develop multiple sets of rinnegan but if so then it would explain why obito/tobi/madara collected all those sharingan during the uchiha massacre +cool points tho for neat theory

 

[Vitvol]

No! that wouldn't makes sense, he was talking to a corpse/ dead person!

You must be registered for see images

No he wasn't. He said it to Konan just before the fight

He never mentioned the Eyes in front of Nagato

You must be registered for see images

 

[coolcomfort]

Its anyway a failed story!

Madara gave his eyes to nagato - obito took the one eye! edo madara got both? WTF? if he revived he shouldnt has got eyes!
Same thing at itachi and sasuke! How a can revived itachi got both eyes!???
kishimoto is maybe a north korean idiot?!

 

[Shalev]

You must be registered for see images

No he wasn't. He said it to Konan just before the fight

He never mentioned the Eyes in front of Nagato

You must be registered for see images

No! after he defeated Konan, he wennt to the "cemetery" and said I'll be taking what is mine."
what chapter number is that? so i may re-read?

 

[Shalev]

Its anyway a failed story!

Madara gave his eyes to nagato - obito took the one eye! edo madara got both? WTF? if he revived he shouldnt has got eyes!
Same thing at itachi and sasuke! How a can revived itachi got both eyes!???
kishimoto is maybe a north korean idiot?!

I agree with you sir!
Lots of plot holes!?

 

[Vitvol]

It's chapter 510, but he doesn't say it.

 

[Hoshi]

well i didn't see this one
maybe translation fail? or something?

 

[coolcomfort]

ye
for example u revive all the uchihas und transplant their eyes then u got mass sharingan user?!

 

[johnny335704]

He was obeying Madara's order. And lying all the time about it.

 

[Scarecrow.]

You again? You seriously need to re-read the manga

 

[Shalev]

It's chapter 510, but he doesn't say it.

What about the anime episode?
thank you for posting the number.

 

[Shalev]

ye
for example u revive all the uchihas und transplant their eyes then u got mass sharingan user?!

Yeah, that is a lot of OP people, that would end everything!
Rinse and repeat that, revive an uchiha and pluck out his or her eyes!
Yes~

 

[Shalev]

You again? You seriously need to re-read the manga

I am, so chill out, serious person.

 

[Vitvol]

What about the anime episode?
thank you for posting the number.

252 and 253 are the anime chapters where Obito fights Konan

 

[6thpathsage]

You must be registered for see images

No he wasn't. He said it to Konan just before the fight

He never mentioned the Eyes in front of Nagato

You must be registered for see images

This is right!