Misconception: Minato didn't know Shiki fujin could be undone

[Bogard]

I only wanted to clear some things up with this thread. The viz translation of manga chapter 619 came out. Some people believed that Minato didn't know Shiki fujin could be undone, but it's not what Minato says in the viz

You must be registered for see images

Like you can see, he isn't surprised Shiki Fujin can be undone, he is surprised by the fact Orochimaru knew how to do so. Reason why Orochimaru tell Minato not to underestimate him and explain him how he knew to undo the jutsu

 

[Unorthodox]

does this means oro is a better sealer than minato i think so

 

[-Raviel-]

Well people who doubt are just trolls/stupid or they just dont read the manga

 

[Yatori]

Means minato also know how to undone the seal rite?

 

[Naoya Minato]

Orochimaru says he knows how to do it by studying the Uzumaki clans documents. Minato himself studied the Uzumaki sealing techniques too. It's only logical for him to know how.

 

[Temporary Account]

So did Minato know how to undo the Shiki Fujin seal? From these Viz translations, it seems not.

 

[iSpeak the Truth]

lol @ "Mister Orochimaru". I guess that just means -San

 

[Bogard]

So did Minato know how to undo the Shiki Fujin seal? From these Viz translations, it seems not.

He wonders how Orochimaru solved how to undo the jutsu, which means he knew the process, but surprised by how Oro knew as well

lol @ "Mister Orochimaru". I guess that just means -San

Haha it's the japanese translation of san i guess. Thanks again for the scan btw

 

[Horus]

Yep

 

[Suiton Master]

he may have been surprised that orochimaru lived through undoing the seal as it needs a sacrifice

 

[iSpeak the Truth]

Haha it's the japanese translation of san i guess. Thanks again for the scan btw

You're welcome

 

[hamer34]

Well people who doubt are just trolls/stupid or they just dont read the manga

how would they know it in the first place

 

[Unorthodox]

He wonders how Orochimaru solved how to undo the jutsu, which means he knew the process, but surprised by how Oro knew as well

Haha it's the japanese translation of san i guess. Thanks again for the scan btw

know it means he surprissed he doesnt know to undo the seal if he did why didnt tell the 3rd or any other ninja in the villiage orochimaru has his ways his intelligence shouldnt be looked down on he is smarter than itachi & minato imo

 

[Stark]

I see, so Minato did know that it can be undone. He was just surprised someone was able to figure out how to undo it, thanks for the clear up.

 

[Temporary Account]

He wonders how Orochimaru solved how to undo the jutsu, which means he knew the process, but surprised by how Oro knew as well

Nah, it could be interpreted in multiple ways. Still, it isn't clear whether or not Minato knew the process on how to undo the Shiki Fujin seal, the dialect in that particular conversation makes it even more confusing. You definitely do have a point though. Minato being the badass he is, he probably already had knowledge regarding it.

 

[Owarij]

Viz still keeps the fact that Minato didn't know HOW , thus he's asking orochimaru to explain..

If there was a method to undo it, and Minato knew, he wouldn't be interested in how to do it

 

[Bogard]

I see, so Minato did know that it can be undone. He was just surprised someone was able to figure out how to undo it, thanks for the clear up.

You're welcome man

Nah, it could be interpreted in multiple ways. Still, it isn't clear whether or not Minato knew the process on how to undo the Shiki Fujin seal, the dialect in that particular conversation makes it even more confusing. You definitely do have a point though. Minato being the badass he is, he probably already had knowledge regarding it.

He is a genius after all :scorps:

Viz still keeps the fact that Minato didn't know HOW , thus he's asking orochimaru to explain..

Nope, he is asking him how he knew the method to undo it. It's clear as day, and thus explaining why Oro tells him not to underestimate him for knowing that

 

[OnPoint]

Hmm, I see what you're saying. It still seems a tad ambiguous though. Is Minato asking how Orochimaru undid the seal, or is he asking how Orochimaru knew how to undo it?

 

[Bogard]

Hmm, I see what you're saying. It still seems a tad ambiguous though. Is Minato asking how Orochimaru undid the seal, or is he asking how Orochimaru knew how to undo it?

You solved how to undo that jutsu. Solve what? an equation? Solve what? The process to undo the jutsu obviously. It's clearly that is what Minato is refering to. The fact Orochimaru tells him not to underestimate him and mentions it's obviously something coming from Uzumaki clan, something he checked, further implies that he is talking about something Minato must know but Orochimaru simply doesn't like the fact Minato underestimate him for knowing something like this

 

[OnPoint]

You solved how to undo that jutsu. Solve what? an equation? Solve what? The process to undo the jutsu obviously. It's clearly that is what Minato is refering to. The fact Orochimaru tells him not to underestimate him and mentions it's obviously something coming from Uzumaki clan, something he checked, further implies that he is talking about something Minato must know but Orochimaru simply doesn't like the fact Minato underestimate him for something like this

alrght bbz i wasnt sure so i jst wntded ur opinon