Itachi vs Tobi (without rinnegan)

[Legendary Broly]

Tobi (without rinnegan) VS Itachi ​

This is a fight between the two using their own powers (that we've seen so far) so :

No rinnegan for Tobi
(assuming its not his, remember this means no rinnegan powers either -.- )
No tailed beasts
tools can be used so Yata mirror , sword of Totsuka i.e and just normal swords you get the point

other then this the rest has no restrictions any other technique of theirs can be used so tobi s/t , genjutsu i.e ..

who wins? they both are very intelligent and have strong range of jutsu's but i think just because tobi is having an identity crisis itachi can use izanami on tobi , because it was designed for the uchiha to accept their fate so also izangi wouldnt work would it, idk you tell me ? but then again tobi has alot of chakra and could last longer then itachi or break out of any genjutsu of itachi's ...
i'm not really sure so who wins ?

 

[~MC117~]

I think tobi would win, itachi doesn't have a way to touch him but genjutsu might work.

 

[TiddlySkydiver]

Tobi, that's why Itachi didn't attempt to kill him.

 

[Legendary Broly]

I think tobi would win, itachi doesn't have a way to touch him but genjutsu might work.

idk.. tobi can only stay intangible continuously for 5 minutes , during the rest period itachi could use Amaterasu ?

 

[~MC117~]

idk.. tobi can only stay intangible continuously for 5 minutes , during the rest period itachi could use Amaterasu ?

Yes but it would be hard for itachi to last those 5 minutes, tobi is very hard to fight when he is intangible so he could kill itachi before he run out of ghost mode.

 

[Legendary Broly]

Yes but it would be hard for itachi to last those 5 minutes, tobi is very hard to fight when he is intangible so he could kill itachi before he run out of ghost mode.

yeah you do have a point but i am sure Itachi would last atleast 5 minutes , konan lasted like 15

 

[~MC117~]

yeah you do have a point but i am sure Itachi would last atleast 5 minutes , konan lasted like 15

She had prep time and tobi wasn't taking her seriously at first.

 

[Cerox0]

Tobi sadly.

 

[Legendary Broly]

She had prep time and tobi wasn't taking her seriously at first.

im not an itachi fb , but i think he deserves a little more credit , he can last longer then 5 minutes , hes smart but he'll have to force tobi to stay continually intangible for 5 minutes though which would drain his chakra .. , then again he has susanoo to block off tobi for a bit ..

 

[USSJ Future Trunks]

tobi goes intangible, goes into the ground and sticks his chains through itachis legs then goes tangible.

 

[Blunt]

As long as he has S/t Itachi has no real way of defeating him.

 

[Drakengard]

His best chance would be an exploding clone or something. Doubt it would work on Tobi though. How does the whole Izanami vs Izanagi thing work anyways? Never quite understood that.

 

[Kurama2012]

i kinda see tobi winning as i dont know what itaichi could do when tobi sucks him in to his dimension and itaichi even stated that he needed ems to be able to beat him

 

[-Madara Uchiha-]

Tobi wins

 

[TobisPawn]

Tobi doesn't have an identity crisis ("I'm no one. I don't want to be anyone"). That said, Tobi's Genjutsu is also very OP (controlling a perfect Jinchuuriki for years on end).

I say Tobi wins due to his S/T techs.

 

[Wolfang714]

Do they have full knowledge of each other's abilities?
If no: Tobi
If yes: Itachi

 

[Legendary Broly]

Do they have full knowledge of each other's abilities?
If no: Tobi
If yes: Itachi

they have the knowledge that they had during itachi's life , so tobi knows all of itachi's abilities seen while he was alive so he doesnt know about izanami and itachi only has knowledge on tobi's abilities before he died

 

[Krynnz]

Tobi, that's why Itachi didn't attempt to kill him.

This.

That's why he triggered Sasuke's sharingan to ameterasu Tobi if he ever saw his sharingan. He knew he was too strong for him and a sucker punch would've been the only way to beat him.

 

[Legendary Broly]

This.

That's why he triggered Sasuke's sharingan to ameterasu Tobi if he ever saw his sharingan. He knew he was too strong for him and a sucker punch would've been the only way to beat him.

good point rep+

 

[Icelerate]

Tobi doesn't have an identity crisis ("I'm no one. I don't want to be anyone"). That said, Tobi's Genjutsu is also very OP (controlling a perfect Jinchuuriki for years on end).

I say Tobi wins due to his S/T techs.

Actually if Tobi says that he is no one than that means he is afraid to admit who he truly is in which case Izanami would definitely work on him. Tobi can't dodge amaterasu but can somehow extinguish those flames. I don't really know how he did it but if he used izanagi than he can only use that technique twice. If Itachi outlasts izanagi than he will win.