Sasuk3Uchiha
Leaf Village Regular 🍃
- Joined
- Dec 22, 2011
- Messages
- 739
- Reaction score
- 95
I've read quite a few threads on these topics (referring either to Sasuke or his Kekkai Genkai, the Sharingan, or both), and while a vast majority have agreed that at this point in the series, the Sharingan is an overpowered technique, I'll be taking the opposing viewpoint; that is, that it isn't. This is merely one person's opinion, and I'm certainly not aiming to change your minds; if anything, I hope at least one of my points influences some of you view things from a different perspective.
Now, whether it was Narutopedia, Wikipedia, or another Anime/Manga based website, most of you already know of the Sharingan's impressive abilities; and for the faithful viewers who've watched/read the series from episode 1 up to now, you've all seen the changes Sasuke's Sharingan has undergone, from it's initial form during the battle with Haku, to it's final form during the final battle with Naruto, to the Mangekyo form achieved after being told the truth about his brother Itachi, and most recently, the Eternal Mangekyo that Sasuke now possesses. What I'm having trouble understanding is how soo many people can say so simply that it's overpowered, especially if you've seen/read all of Sasuke's battles involving his use of the Sharingan - the last time I checked, very few of those battles were easy ones.
Example 1: Sasuke Vs. Rock Lee
While his Sharingan was only in its secondary stage, Sasuke still wasn't able to beat Lee, even with the ability to perceive Lee's movements, because his body wasn't quick enough to react accordingly. In this case, even though Sasuke possessed the superior ability, the Sharingan was useless during this battle.
Example 2: Sasuke Vs. Naruto
When facing Naruto at the Valley of the End, after his Sharingan entered its complete stage, Sasuke did have the edge over Naruto, but he still wasn't impervious to attacks (Naruto was still able to drag him under water with his clones and sling him into the rocks) Also, once Naruto activated the Fox shroud, his Sharingan wasn't able to read all of Naruto's movements in order to avoid all of the attacks (partly due to the shroud attacking on it's own) Again, in this case, the Sharingan wasn't invincible.
Example 3: Sasuke Vs. Killer Bee
2 Years later, even after having completely mastered the Sharingan, and with access to the Mangekyo, Sasuke nonetheless struggled to take down Killer Bee (Or rather, 1 tentacle of Bee's Tailed Beast). Even with the Sharingan's amazing clarity of perception, and Sasuke's skill with it, he still couldn't keep track of Bee's blades, and wound up getting impaled; using Tsukuyomi also proved nearly fatal, as he would've lost his life after taking Bee's Lariat, were it not for Jugo's quick thinking.
Example 4: Sasuke Vs. Raikage
In this battle, the Mangekyo was used more than the orginal Sharingan, and yet, Sasuke still couldn't bring down the Raikage. He couldn't track his movements due to the Raikage's Lighting-Style Body Flicker Technique, and while his strategy of using Amaterasu with his Susano'o ribcage seemed foolproof, the Raikage instantly changed our perception of that idea (though at the cost of his arm).
"Okay, that may be true, but look at the techniques Sasuke has at his disposal - Amaterasu, Tsukuyomi, & most importantly, Susano'o - Don't you think they're a little too much?" Is the reply I expect from some of you, and I do agree, those techniques are insanely powerful, and are my favorite ones, to be perfectly honest. However, all three of share a near-fatal consequence, the loss of one's sight, which is, obviously important for someone with that Kekkai Genkai. Each and every time Itachi/Sasuke have used those abilities, their eyesight has suffered drastically, and Susano'o has the greatest drawback, since it draws its power not only from chakra, but from the very life force of its user as well.
With all that being said, anyone who has read/watched the series and is aware of all of this, shouldn't be so quick to say that the Sharingan is an overpowered Kekkei Genkai. It is a powerful ability, no doubt, but it does have it's limitations, and the MS has severe drawbacks; furthermore, as Zetsu said during Sasuke's battle with Itachi, 'The strength of the Sharingan depends on the skill of its user' - If that is the case, it only goes to show that Sasuke and Itachi are quite adept with their use of this ability.
Now, in terms of the Eternal Mangekyo, I can agree with the statement that it is overpowered, considering it possesses no current drawbacks (at least not that have been revealed yet). However, until Sasuke makes his appearance in the manga, the jury is out for this one.
Feel free to leave your opinions, comments, or rebuttals; I'll do my best to answer/comment on them.
Now, whether it was Narutopedia, Wikipedia, or another Anime/Manga based website, most of you already know of the Sharingan's impressive abilities; and for the faithful viewers who've watched/read the series from episode 1 up to now, you've all seen the changes Sasuke's Sharingan has undergone, from it's initial form during the battle with Haku, to it's final form during the final battle with Naruto, to the Mangekyo form achieved after being told the truth about his brother Itachi, and most recently, the Eternal Mangekyo that Sasuke now possesses. What I'm having trouble understanding is how soo many people can say so simply that it's overpowered, especially if you've seen/read all of Sasuke's battles involving his use of the Sharingan - the last time I checked, very few of those battles were easy ones.
Example 1: Sasuke Vs. Rock Lee
While his Sharingan was only in its secondary stage, Sasuke still wasn't able to beat Lee, even with the ability to perceive Lee's movements, because his body wasn't quick enough to react accordingly. In this case, even though Sasuke possessed the superior ability, the Sharingan was useless during this battle.
Example 2: Sasuke Vs. Naruto
When facing Naruto at the Valley of the End, after his Sharingan entered its complete stage, Sasuke did have the edge over Naruto, but he still wasn't impervious to attacks (Naruto was still able to drag him under water with his clones and sling him into the rocks) Also, once Naruto activated the Fox shroud, his Sharingan wasn't able to read all of Naruto's movements in order to avoid all of the attacks (partly due to the shroud attacking on it's own) Again, in this case, the Sharingan wasn't invincible.
Example 3: Sasuke Vs. Killer Bee
2 Years later, even after having completely mastered the Sharingan, and with access to the Mangekyo, Sasuke nonetheless struggled to take down Killer Bee (Or rather, 1 tentacle of Bee's Tailed Beast). Even with the Sharingan's amazing clarity of perception, and Sasuke's skill with it, he still couldn't keep track of Bee's blades, and wound up getting impaled; using Tsukuyomi also proved nearly fatal, as he would've lost his life after taking Bee's Lariat, were it not for Jugo's quick thinking.
Example 4: Sasuke Vs. Raikage
In this battle, the Mangekyo was used more than the orginal Sharingan, and yet, Sasuke still couldn't bring down the Raikage. He couldn't track his movements due to the Raikage's Lighting-Style Body Flicker Technique, and while his strategy of using Amaterasu with his Susano'o ribcage seemed foolproof, the Raikage instantly changed our perception of that idea (though at the cost of his arm).
"Okay, that may be true, but look at the techniques Sasuke has at his disposal - Amaterasu, Tsukuyomi, & most importantly, Susano'o - Don't you think they're a little too much?" Is the reply I expect from some of you, and I do agree, those techniques are insanely powerful, and are my favorite ones, to be perfectly honest. However, all three of share a near-fatal consequence, the loss of one's sight, which is, obviously important for someone with that Kekkai Genkai. Each and every time Itachi/Sasuke have used those abilities, their eyesight has suffered drastically, and Susano'o has the greatest drawback, since it draws its power not only from chakra, but from the very life force of its user as well.
With all that being said, anyone who has read/watched the series and is aware of all of this, shouldn't be so quick to say that the Sharingan is an overpowered Kekkei Genkai. It is a powerful ability, no doubt, but it does have it's limitations, and the MS has severe drawbacks; furthermore, as Zetsu said during Sasuke's battle with Itachi, 'The strength of the Sharingan depends on the skill of its user' - If that is the case, it only goes to show that Sasuke and Itachi are quite adept with their use of this ability.
Now, in terms of the Eternal Mangekyo, I can agree with the statement that it is overpowered, considering it possesses no current drawbacks (at least not that have been revealed yet). However, until Sasuke makes his appearance in the manga, the jury is out for this one.
Feel free to leave your opinions, comments, or rebuttals; I'll do my best to answer/comment on them.
Last edited:
