[Game] AnimeBase Mafia Players Game!!! #29

AngelusSama

Member
Joined
Dec 24, 2019
Messages
286
Kin
321💸
Kumi
9💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
It was a theory last phase which is why I went for Poison. I gave her the benefit of doubt in 1st phase and she didn't convince me since. I did the same for Michelle and SK.
And Michelle is convincing to me. SK is not.

And it was a theory last phase but I have more reasons to believe SK is scum compared to others now.
Yes I believe SoulKiller could be scum. But I still not convinced Michelle isn't scum unless she can give me very good reasons why she never pushed SoulKiller in the last DP. I saw her player list and there's no SK name inside her town/town lean list. Even inside null list.

I can give her a pass if before she had SK as town but changing her mind after she found something suspicious about SK later on.

Even if she don't want to vote him at least give us a clear read on SK in the last dp.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rej

SoulKiller

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Dec 3, 2012
Messages
12,289
Kin
2,433💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I also want to say I didn't like how Soul specifically commented and chose to sit on the fence when Ratchet and I were going at it.
I did not sit on the fence, I literally stated my opinion regarding and how I genuinely felt about it. I said entering it i had W/T interaction and viewed ratchet as scum. After the iso i was not sure who is the scum anymore and that there was a chance it was TvT

everyone else did not do anything regard your 1v1 and decided to stay on the fence about it. Yet because i actually iso'ed you two and came up with my own honest conclusion I am scummy for it? how does that make sense?
 

Sagebee

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Aug 13, 2016
Messages
20,837
Kin
6,121💸
Kumi
1,800💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
There are other reasons and its a non claim setup so I can't get into more details.

But Sage please do try to understand why we are sussing SK.

He will put wallies to no end and it almost always tends to mislead.

There is a reason why Michelle, Rej and I are the hardest on his ass atm.
Coz its literally deja vu. Same thing happened in Alice's game and he was scum.
@SoulKiller you want to call bs?
 

SoulKiller

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Dec 3, 2012
Messages
12,289
Kin
2,433💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
After have been reading D4 posts

My simple read as of below;



Rej vs SK

Town vs Wolf

You're genuinely trying to sort and solve while SoulKiller is looking more in the mode of accusing and framing.


Rej vs ted

Town vs Town

For TSQ I think he's Town for his voting actions in the last DP. I can't see scum playing like that without any reason being presented.


SK vs Mich

Wolf vs Wolf

I don't know how to explain it better. Ok from my observation I have a feeling that their act from last DP until now could be staged. I think there's something about SoulKiller that we doesn't know and Michelle didn't want to poke it in the last DP and knowing that SoulKiller is surely once again going to be a focus of many people in the next DP Michelle know this is the right time to poke it. IMO


Toujo vs X

Town(before&after flip) vs Wolf

Why XTMF is wolf to me because 1)His warning against Wolf that I think it's a fake warning to fool Town to think XTMF could be town. 2)His activity in this game. 3) His overly fixation on Toujo and his vote that basically just a counter to Toujo. It looked more like an OMGUS Vote. I believe if he thinks he can stay with that vote for many DPs he's not going to move away. 4)Not widened his scum hunt.


ted vs Toujo

Town vs Town



Tigerrr looks much better now after I Have ISO her.

Alice. I need more time to understand her. I'm watching her closely.

Poison is not looking that good in my eyes after I'm looking at her activity in the last DP, especially the part where she tells people her opinion about the people who she's okay getting lynched.
Aight, what are your thoughts regarding the other players? who is scum beside me, Michelle, and X? opinions about players who are being inactive and taking a backseat?
 

Michelle

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
12,170
Kin
9,030💸
Kumi
3,787💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Alright Michelle, you avoided me like a plague last DP
Look at yourself you are a plague.
I'm here now for the next few days so my energy should be renewed and I'm ready to answer any questions and engage this game with a renewed effort.
Please share reads after you catch up.
I am hughly suspicious because SK came with the same idea like you that i have no contribution. My play time was so limited and yet i played the game like i will demonstrate for Sagebee and i will @ you with it.
If you are villager and have the mindset of the past game this will be visible because in the other game you townsided.
SK vs Mich

Wolf vs Wolf

I don't know how to explain it better. Ok from my observation I have a feeling that their act from last DP until now could be staged. I think there's something about SoulKiller that we doesn't know and Michelle didn't want to poke it in the last DP and knowing that SoulKiller is surely once again going to be a focus of many people in the next DP Michelle know this is the right time to poke it. IMO
I thought i say it clearly. I was role playing Is not i didn't want to poke the big SK, I wanted to see what is happening if i let him be and tried to find his mates. Looks like i wasn't so successful but maybe after my mislynch you will reconsider
Let's start, yes I know your scum game, I saw you play scum
Really? when and where?
and you are passive as hell when you are scum
Nice, tell me more..
I am not passive here. I was just ignoring you, did you die being neglected?
Don't come to me and blame your passiveness as "roleplaying" because if that's the case then how come you are super active this DP huh? already starting with a lie.
Play time is different from day to day. and your assumptions are just stretches.
Exposing Michelle part 2
is more exposing yourself tbh. Nothing there except big lies.
Michelle flip can prove my point about them, about my idea.
Why don't you flip SK? Is for you w/w anyway? When he flips wolf will you consider this wolf theatre? Are you for real?
 

-PK-

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Apr 30, 2013
Messages
4,240
Kin
797💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Please state those reasons because as I'm looking at the soul case so far it's pretty flimsy from all going after him
I think its a playstyle clash.
You might think my case is flimsy while I think its good enough.

Do I think SK is scum? Yes
Am I 100% sure? No
Am I willing to take that risk? Yes
Am I okay if you come after me if I turn out to be wrong? Absolutely.

I don't think there is ever a 100% certainty in mafia specially in a role madness game like this until there is a flip so yea. If this is what it takes to move the game forward I am willing to bet my ass on the line.

Idk who asked me earlier that after SK who i will go for?
But
Regardless of his flip. Next in line for me are Poison/TSQ then perhaps X.
I have stated this multiple times already now.
 

Michelle

Active member
Legendary
Joined
Jul 3, 2008
Messages
12,170
Kin
9,030💸
Kumi
3,787💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Yes I believe SoulKiller could be scum. But I still not convinced Michelle isn't scum unless she can give me very good reasons why she never pushed SoulKiller in the last DP. I saw her player list and there's no SK name inside her town/town lean list. Even inside null list.

I can give her a pass if before she had SK as town but changing her mind after she found something suspicious about SK later on.

Even if she don't want to vote him at least give us a clear read on SK in the last dp.
I put him in the bottom of the list saying he is the Alpha and Omega of mafia hinting he is the Alpha wolf. Maybe my role play is bad but i tried at least.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Rej
Top