[Game] SK-Tower Of God! The Great War!!! #28

[TheLukundo]

I am going to go ahead and town read Poison because I want to keep my team mafia teamy alive.
Haters gonna hate.

K

 

[TheLukundo]

No comment as to where you're siding? I think X has been all over Poison thus far.

It feels like it’s gonna escalate and it shouldn’t have any reason to.

 

[Poison]

give your reads first

Luk is probably town. Feels like his last town game. But I'll give proper reads later. I don't have time right now.

Official bye.

 

[TheLukundo]

Do you disagree? I mean it's a little weird to be getting into this now before we've even had a night phase, but it seems like a common enougn estimate to me.

Just a tad

 

[AL_sama]

Luk is probably town. Feels like his last town game. But I'll give proper reads later. I don't have time right now.

Official bye.

huh the hell is this??

 

[Rej]

Thanks this helps.
I like Rej until now, Poison and idk what to do with the new players tbh. Not yet.

ookay, i will give more details.
yes
tnx 4 patience ^^

oh yes, let's town together

I don't know if I've ever heard a newbie speak with such confidence.

same, but he is motivated to learn, also his first 2 games here he rand mafia I think lmao

he is another person this game and tries new more townier things in nature

someone beat me on this

 

[Aether9]

O. It wasn’t a joke BTW.

if so, ist it weird how you want to depend on him when he didnt even posted, how do you even know if he is town or not?

How so?

because you want to lynch him just form that analysis I am assuming, how are you sure he is scum just from that?

 

[TheLukundo]

if so, ist it weird how you want to depend on him when he didnt even posted, how do you even know if he is town or not?

He had posted...

 

[Toujo]

No. You wouldn’t. Youd reeval because otherwise you’re blatantly setting up another lynch which is scummy af. Especially as you could just flip town now. “Oh these 2 aren’t scum but we’ll lynch one and if they flip town, we’ll flip the other”

THAT AINT A TOWN LOGIC

What, no? If you believe two players are scum, why would you let both off the hook because you can't quite fit them as a partnership? Like I'm hesitent to continue this as it feels like we ae getting into mafia philosophy, but why does it seem like you believe interactions between scummates are the be all and end all here? Obviously if I'm presenting it as only these two lynches, then that's scummy, as it's a fallacy. But we're talking about reads here. How many games have you played, may I ask? Because this feels like a very strange way to approach scumhunting, and I can't imagine it has been very successful.

 

[Toujo]

Just a tad

Explain.

 

[Rej]

Okay, I can do that. I have a bigger post in the works where I'm summarising it so I'll be sure to revisit these things so make it clearer. For reference though, I have the following early readys

Imp - scum
X - town
Poison - scum
you - scum*

*I'm curious with this one, because Michelle's response to my statement (that by her established criteria, you would fit scum more) was to deflect it to "I'm known for that". I'm in flux here, because if Michelle indeed can't read you as well as she says you can, this puts this whole interaction between the two of you into a different light. So while it's scum for now, once I engage further with Michelle this could flip.

Just to slash inside this read list, why X is town for you?
I don't have doubts on the read, just out of curiosity since both you and him are newer players I play with.

 

[Aether9]

He had posted...

I dont remember him posting a single time, if you quote that, it would be better

 

[beeboat]

page 2: luk thinks(unbiased) him and michelle are scummate, though I am clueless and might be jokes. imperfection plans to analyze later on everyone. though in page 2 luk is looking better with him explaining.

This feels fake, someone calls himself scum and he is not postive it's a joke kinda weird?

page 3: luk brings up michelle no selling luk's claim and michelle dismisses luk and poison kinda agrees with michelle and thinks luk is scummy though its fluff.

mich?

Restating events.

page 4: al votes ryu, michelle votes ratchet

so far we've got michelle vs luk and poison vs luk.

Restating

page 5: a lot of fluff posts, though liked al's post




ddint liked this though again could be jock

Technically a thought but still feels like going through motions of restating events.



vote: Aether9

 

[Rej]

Teamy hi hi!!
We can use this game to practice catching scum together B)))))

the question beforehand is if anyone of you guys is town

 

[beeboat]

I have half the game left to read but I am chilling with my vote so far.

 

[Aether9]

oh yes, let's town together

same, but he is motivated to learn, also his first 2 games here he rand mafia I think lmao

he is another person this game and tries new more townier things in nature

someone beat me on this

what do you guys have so far :hmm

 

[Ryu Kishi]

not liking how fast you pulled your vote back here

bad


bad


bad


good

You must be registered for see images

Anway I'm not liking @Aether9 you seem scum to me.

 

[Toujo]

Just to slash inside this read list, why X is town for you?
I don't have doubts on the read, just out of curiosity since both you and him are newer players I play with.

just a weak meta read. It's a slight town read, just notable enough for me to mention it.

 

[Aether9]

You must be registered for see images

Anway I'm not liking @Aether9 you seem scum to me.

explain?

 

[Michelle]

I do believe there is enough but ok lol

i need your towniness. Didn't see a towntell i am expecting.

Your criteria had Luk acting more seriously as town. That was not my impression of his posting, particularly at the start of the day phase. In fact it was quite the opposite - behaviour which you described as NAI. Do you see my issue here?
You're conflating seperate points here. By missing something, I'm referring to what I'm missing in regards to how you read Luk. As for not having enough town reads, I mean not really. I've got my vote on one person right now, and it's on none of the three on my scum list. To claim I'm simply looking for mislynch bait here is a horrible mischaracterisation of my play thus far, which makes me think you're either not playing attention or your're baiting.
Elaborate on this.

1. about Luke's meta. I said already his posts don't have much and obvious difference. Many people can't say it. He always fluffs a thread untill is filled with his one liners and between these posts some have that serious tone i was talking about. There are few more here and i didn't note any of them but his post with reads is easy to spot as serious.
Nothing from what i said is contradicting except you are nitpicky and want to find something where is nothing.

2. I don't like your tone in that post. Is that simple. I don't make sophisticated or educated guesses, i openly think that if you link people like you did in the post where you put 3 scum reads and 1 TR the possibility of you to be scum and start a narrative there is high.