Suicide-worthy circumstances?

[Guardian of the Rain]

Most people who have committed suicide get accused of giving up too early and being called "quitters".

What kind of unfavorable situation does a person need to be in for you to not blame someone for ending their own life? How intolerable would one's life have to be for you to clearly understand why they decided to end it all?

Sacrificing oneself and being a hero is an obvious one. Same with killing oneself to escape unbearable physical pain. Choose another please.
Emotion-related answers preferred.


Btw, sorry for the depressing question and topic of discussion. My curiosity was too strong not to ask

 

[slimreaper]

Most people who have committed suicide get accused of giving up too early and being called "quitters".

What kind of unfavorable situation does a person need to be in for you to not blame someone for ending their own life?
Sacrificing oneself and being a hero is an obvious one. Choose another please.

Btw, sorry for the depressing question and topic of discussion. My curiosity was too strong not to ask

i think jumping from an already burning building like 9/11 is pretty ok. It's either burn to death or splat on the ground

 

[The Amazing Spider Man]

If you get raped by a gang of gay dudes you have no other choice but to kill yourself.

 

[Venomous Cobra]

What kind of unfavorable situation does a person need to be in for you to not blame someone for ending their own life?

I think you might want to rephrase that question. I would blame anyone for their suicide regardless of the situation, some cases are tolerable, though the simple fact that one is always responsible for their suicide always remains.

whether it's right/wrong that is a different story.

 

[Guardian of the Rain]

Running out of Pop Tarts.

Well, if you eat Pop Tarts that much, you'll die prematurely anyway lol

If leo didn't win an oscar this year, then i saw no other reason for him to continue with life.

...that would've been sucky indeed, but not worth dying over especially since he would've still been a rich and wildly successful ladies' man haha

If you get raped by a gang of gay dudes you have no other choice but to kill yourself.

Agreed

i think jumping from an already burning building like 9/11 is pretty ok. It's either burn to death or splat on the ground

I'd take splat on the ground all day, so I agree

 

[lord seventh]

Cowardice but still its better to know their situation first

 

[Guardian of the Rain]

I think you might want to rephrase that question. I would blame anyone for their suicide regardless of the situation, some cases are tolerable, though the simple fact that one is always responsible for their suicide always remains.

whether it's right/wrong that is a different story.

The "blame" is for a lack of a better word. I think most people know what I'm asking. "Tolerable" is a good word though

 

[BlacLord™]

Any situation where there's no chance of enjoying life again, cause that's all we really live for. We'd hardly seek to live 80+ years if it was constant agony from the year dot.

 

[The Work]

Lose male genitals.

 

[Guardian of the Rain]

Cowardice but still its better to know their situation first

Why you people claim suicide victims to be cowards is beyond me. "Quitters" I can understand. Cowards? lol wut

Sure, in some circumstances, they may have been literally afraid of something or someone. But wtf were they afraid of if they killed themselves because they knew that, without a doubt, they had no future? I'm sure most of them tried extremely hard to better their lives, but just couldn't.

You'd prefer people keep living just for the sake of living? To be wastes of space?
Only if someone has dependents like children, spouse; and/or elderly relative, then they shouldn't kill themselves. But if no one needs them alive, then I don't see a problem with suicide.

It's selfish to want people to keep pointlessly suffering. No one knows what suicide victims were truly going through unless they wrote an in-depth suicide note.

Any situation where there's no chance of enjoying life again, cause that's all we really live for. We'd hardly seek to live 80+ years if it was constant agony from the year dot.

Good point. I think people who want to live to be 100 are crazy. Different strokes for different folks, I guess

Lose male genitals.

I would say that I could do without testicles, but no testicles means no...explosion. Therefore just having a dong would be lame and pleasure-less, so I agree with you, too

 

[DominiqueX]

Any situation where there's no chance of enjoying life again, cause that's all we really live for. We'd hardly seek to live 80+ years if it was constant agony from the year dot.

This.
Also, I don't blame people if they commit suicide. Of course it is sad, but every person is unique and sees things in his/her unique way, so we can't understand their situation completely. Everyone has the right to end his own live, as long as they don't take others with them.

 

[loj]

Being a hero when suicide? Eh? You become a whimp who can't deal with his problems.That's what suicide people are.Whimps.You put your family in such a bad state for you to "feel" better...everyone who suicide is a whimp and scardy cats.


No circumstance is a suicide stance.

 

[Ludicrous]

Seppuku ftw. Do not dishonor the family name!!!

OT: It's acceptable when the person feels it's appropriate. How would we know their pain? Of course, I'm not condoning it.

 

[Lightbringer]

Pretty much the two you've listed are the only justifiable reasons in my eyes.

 

[Yatori]

Being a hero when suicide? Eh? You become a whimp who can't deal with his problems.That's what suicide people are.Whimps.You put your family in such a bad state for you to "feel" better...everyone who suicide is a whimp and scardy cats.


No circumstance is a suicide stance.

I agree with this. There are thousands people who have greater problem than yours and you want to commit suicide? Smh

 

[Dark Sonic]

Being a hero when suicide? Eh? You become a whimp who can't deal with his problems.That's what suicide people are.Whimps.You put your family in such a bad state for you to "feel" better...everyone who suicide is a whimp and scardy cats.


No circumstance is a suicide stance.

I sort of agree. It's selfish when there's a family that can help you and be there when things go downhill...

 

[loj]

I sort of agree. It's selfish when there's a family that can help you and be there when things go downhill...

I agree with this. There are thousands people who have greater problem than yours and you want to commit suicide? Smh

Exactly...

 

[DominiqueX]

You become a whimp who can't deal with his problems.That's what suicide people are.Whimps.You put your family in such a bad state for you to "feel" better...everyone who suicide is a whimp and scardy cats.

No circumstance is a suicide stance.

I agree with this. There are thousands people who have greater problem than yours and you want to commit suicide? Smh

You are really disrespectful. You seem to have no idea what a hopeless situation is.
Let me ask you something.

Did you ever experience a cruel disease in your family, for example cancer? Did you ever share your daily life with a person that is incurable sick, a person that almost can't make it through the day even with the highest possible dose of morphine to reduce the overall pain in the body a tiny bit? If that was the case, you wouldn't talk about this topic in a way like this.

I experienced that.
My father had cancer with metastases in almost every single organ and within the bones. I've seen him crying out of pain while begging to die. He couldn't walk, he couldn't eat. He couldn't go to the toilet or even take a bath. He lost his ability to speak or to remember the easiest things. His last one and a half years consisted only of pain, fear, desperation and suffering.

Don't you think a person in this situation should have the right to avoid all this in order to end his/her life with dignity?
You talk about "bringing sorrow to the family", but the truth is, his suffering was what brought sorrow to himself and the rest of my family. If I ever end up in a similar situation, I will end my life before it becomes such a disaster.

Living just for the sake of being alive or to "please the family", that is just ignorance.

 

[TimothyTheTomato]

Accidentally killing your family in a fire caused by you leaving the iron or stove on

 

[Yatori]

You are really disrespectful. You seem to have no idea what a hopeless situation is.
Let me ask you something.

Did you ever experience a cruel disease in your family, for example cancer? Did you ever share your daily life with a person that is incurable sick, a person that almost can't make it through the day even with the highest possible dose of morphine to reduce the overall pain in the body a tiny bit? If that was the case, you wouldn't talk about this topic in a way like this.

I experienced that.
My father had cancer with metastases in almost every single organ and within the bones. I've seen him crying out of pain while begging to die. He couldn't walk, he couldn't eat. He couldn't go to the toilet or even take a bath. He lost his ability to speak or to remember the easiest things. His last one and a half years consisted only of pain, fear, desperation and suffering.

Don't you think a person in this situation should have the right to avoid all this in order to end his/her life with dignity?
You talk about "bringing sorrow to the family", but the truth is, his suffering was what brought sorrow to himself and the rest of my family. If I ever end up in a similar situation, I will end my life before it becomes such a disaster.

Living just for the sake of being alive or to "please the family", that is just ignorance.

Lol so you think you the only one on this problem? Do you still have other family? Have friends? Or have you ever been kicked out of house? Have you left with like 50 dollar only to survive for month with whole family? Have you encaunter war where all your home is burn and destroyed? Are you the only one with family have cancer? Others has it worst and they didnt choose suicide as last attepmt. So dont accused others people ignorant if you still able to living and you still not at the bottom of the world yet!


It is painful and all but others people surviving and keep moving on. So act like you the only has it worst.