What if...

[Zzz]

Hey guys.
So, I was wondering about something.
Kaguya was the first one to use the Infinite Tsukuyomi, right? That jutsu requires reflection on the surface of the moon in order to work. However, Hagoromo was said to have created the moon on his deathbed, and at that time, Kaguya should have been long gone.

My point is, is it possible that Hagoromo creating the moon is just a false phrase?

 

[Snape Uchiha]

1) Kaguya stole the fruit
2) Ten tails attacked
3) SO6P Sealed the Ten Tails chakra and sealed its body in he moon
4) Kaguya attempted IT.

 

[Snape Uchiha]

Accidental double post NB won't let me delete.

 

[Zzz]

1) Kaguya stole the fruit
2) Ten tails attacked
3) SO6P Sealed the Ten Tails chakra and sealed its body in he moon
4) Kaguya attempted IT.

So6P was said to seal the husk of the Juubi (The Mazou) into the moon and divide its chakra from the Mazou on his deathbed.

 

[G Godly 0 forms 0]

the Viz translation seems to Imply Kaguya was gone when the sons fought the juubi,

she did have the byakugan, maybe it was a substitution for the moon

 

[Snape Uchiha]

So6P was said to seal the husk of the Juubi (The Mazou) into the moon and divide its chakra from the Mazou on his deathbed.

Who says Kaguya didn't outlive SO6P?

 

[Snape Uchiha]

same as before

 

[DoubleKamui]

the Viz translation seems to Imply Kaguya was gone when the sons fought the juubi,

she did have the byakugan, maybe it was a substitution for the moon

Can you show me a scan that suggests this? Just curious.

 

[Zzz]

the Viz translation seems to Imply Kaguya was gone when the sons fought the juubi,

she did have the byakugan, maybe it was a substitution for the moon

Who knows. In the latest chapter, Kaguya's figure was shown smiling upon the world, with the moon resembling her third eye, which kinda implies that she also used the moon.

 

[Zzz]

Who says Kaguya didn't outlive SO6P?

She would've fought the Ten-Tails herself, not send two of her inferior children to fight a god.

 

[G Godly 0 forms 0]

Can you show me a scan that suggests this? Just curious.

here you go

You must be registered for see images

Hagoromo: we brothers, to atone for the crimes Mother left behind...


left behind could mean passing away

 

[G Godly 0 forms 0]

Who knows. In the latest chapter, Kaguya's figure was shown smiling upon the world, with the moon resembling her third eye, which kinda implies that she also used the moon.

that would mean, After the bijuus were created, hmm, hagoromo at the time should be an old man,

 

[Zzz]

that would mean, After the bijuus were created, hmm, hagoromo at the time should be an old man,

He was an old man when he created the Tailed Beasts.

 

[G Godly 0 forms 0]

He was an old man when he created the Tailed Beasts.

yes.. the time he made the bijuus was when the moon was made.

 

[DoubleKamui]

here you go

You must be registered for see images

Hagoromo: we brothers, to atone for the crimes Mother left behind...


left behind could mean passing away

Yeah it could mean that she passed away and left her sins behind but it could also mean that she left her crimes behind when she was still alive. After all, it all started when Kaguya ate the fruit. Who knows. Though, I find it hard to believe that Kaguya lived longer than her sons.

 

[Awkward Linguist]

Kaguya used Infinite Tsukuyomi? Any manga scan to support your claim? And if you really think she did use it, then what makes you think that everyone else is in "reality"? Or maybe the whole manga was "part" of the dream that Kaguya cast them on. Honestly, common sense bro.

 

[ShiroShonen]

here you go

You must be registered for see images

Hagoromo: we brothers, to atone for the crimes Mother left behind...


left behind could mean passing away

Nice find

 

[Zzz]

yes.. the time he made the bijuus was when the moon was made.

However, Kaguya was said to have cast the Mugen Tsukuyomi before Hagoromo created the moon, which implies that he actually didn't.

 

[DoubleKamui]

Kaguya used Infinite Tsukuyomi? Any manga scan to support your claim? And if you really think she did use it, then what makes you think that everyone else is in "reality"? Or maybe the whole manga was "part" of the dream that Kaguya cast them on. Honestly, common sense bro.

If she did use it, someone probably undid the jutsu just like Naruto, Sasuke and the Edo Hokages are attempting to do, now.

 

[Zol]

It's really something contradictory that is yet to be explained.

For all we know, Kaguya ruled the land through force, then Hagoromo took over and tried to teach people a different way (ninshuu, mutual understanding). We have no indication at all that Kaguya was still around when Hagoromo was the Rikudo. It's pretty unbelievable she would let him try his way that was completely diferent than hers if she was still around.

Then again, there are many things not yet explained, forinstance, if there was an Infinite Tsukuyomi, how was it broken? Hagoromo didn't adress the IT at all when he first told his story chronologically. He only mentioned it later in reference to Madara...