Madara>Hashirama

Status
Not open for further replies.

Flawž

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
12,247
Reaction score
1,407
What about before that?
Hold up.
*clicks Madara on speed dial and waits*

We have no idea before that. Anything said before that is pure speculation.

What we do now is that the two times we saw madara vs hashirama fight, Madara was immobilized in both situations.

Thus we can conclude that he was immobilized and couldn't control hashirama.
 

Recable

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Aug 15, 2012
Messages
1,193
Reaction score
82
Just to say, Madara doesn't currently have his eyes if you see at the start of the chapter his eyes disappear, then later on in the chapter he says "Until my Rinnegan comes back, I guess I could take your eyes" so this clearly proves he currently doesn't have his eyes making him only currently having Hashirama's Sage Mode. That's not enough to make it Madara > Hashirama, at the moment it's Hashirama > Madara.
 

Troyg39

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 11, 2010
Messages
3,369
Reaction score
561
Madara was bound by the wood dragon when we saw hashirama with chakra rods.

Madara was still immobilized again as the wood dragon was draining him from chakra.

Then before the wood dragon part, Hashirama clearly had the rods already in his back. So whenever Madara placed those rods in his back, which we just confirmed was before Madara was bound, Madara technically had a chance to control him then.

In simpler terms, Madara was in a position to control Hashirama before Hashirama was able to bind him since the rods were already in Hashirama's back by the time we saw Hashirama first bind Madara.

Just because you don't see Madara putting the rods in Hashi's back, the fact that they are Madara's rods and they were in Hashi's back before the wood dragon incident confirms they were placed there before Hashirama had him bound

I'm assuming this is what Hipster Madara is trying to convey to you. I'm not saying your overall argument is incorrect, I'm just trying to help you two not continue this back and forth. Because at this point you guys are arguing two different points and that's probably why you haven't found any middle ground yet
 

Hipster Madara

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 13, 2010
Messages
16,212
Reaction score
1,556
We have no idea before that. Anything said before that is pure speculation.

What we do now is that the two times we saw madara vs hashirama fight, Madara was immobilized in both situations.

Thus we can conclude that he was immobilized and couldn't control hashirama.

Then before the wood dragon part, Hashirama clearly had the rods already in his back. So whenever Madara placed those rods in his back, which we just confirmed was before Madara was bound, Madara technically had a chance to control him then.

In simpler terms, Madara was in a position to control Hashirama before Hashirama was able to bind him since the rods were already in Hashirama's back by the time we saw Hashirama first bind Madara.

I'm assuming this is what Hipster Madara is trying to convey to you. I'm not saying your overall argument is incorrect, I'm just trying to help you two not continue this back and forth. Because at this point you guys are arguing two different points and that's probably why you haven't found any middle ground yet
^^
This, I ALREADY said this. :|

But wait up a sec, Imma check.

[video=youtube;UgcqZE4QB7Q]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UgcqZE4QB7Q[/video]
Hipster Madara: Yo, Madara, dawg. We have been wondering whether you stabbed Hashirama with the black rods before you got sealed or not. If you have down time while fighting the entire shinobi world, call us at 1-800-THEWINNER
Thanks.
 

Flawž

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
12,247
Reaction score
1,407
Then before the wood dragon part, Hashirama clearly had the rods already in his back. So whenever Madara placed those rods in his back, which we just confirmed was before Madara was bound, Madara technically had a chance to control him then.

In simpler terms, Madara was in a position to control Hashirama before Hashirama was able to bind him since the rods were already in Hashirama's back by the time we saw Hashirama first bind Madara.

Just because you don't see Madara putting the rods in Hashi's back, the fact that they are Madara's rods and they were in Hashi's back before the wood dragon incident confirms they were placed there before Hashirama had him bound

I'm assuming this is what Hipster Madara is trying to convey to you. I'm not saying your overall argument is incorrect, I'm just trying to help you two not continue this back and forth. Because at this point you guys are arguing two different points and that's probably why you haven't found any middle ground yet

speculation. We don't know what happened in that part of the fight. For all we know madara got a lucky shot and got the rods in madara's back when hashirama finally caught him with the wood dragon and immobilized him.

What we know is that in both instances, madara was movement restricted and was unable to move.
 

Multiply

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Apr 15, 2012
Messages
12,839
Reaction score
1,034
You must be registered for see images

You must be registered for see images
 

Hipster Madara

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 13, 2010
Messages
16,212
Reaction score
1,556
speculation. We don't know what happened in that part of the fight. For all we know madara got a lucky shot and got the rods in madara's back when hashirama finally caught him with the wood dragon and immobilized him.

What we know is that in both instances, madara was movement restricted and was unable to move.
He got a lucky shot 4 times (simultaneously while being chased according to you) which were clearly at different times (coming in at different directions)....I don't buy that at all. :|

I'm not saying that the winner can be determined, because Hashirama isn't at full. But I'm saying that Madara could have tried harder and used more of his jutsus/advantages during the fight. It clearly wasn't a full fight as their last one took 1 night and this one was barely 2 hrs so stop using this as proof that Madara < Hashirama. That is simply speculation on your part.
 

Meekz89

Jōnin Strategist 🧠
Regular
Joined
Mar 14, 2012
Messages
1,560
Reaction score
89
The only thing I see happening is Madara is showing off some of Hashiramas techniques. Healing himself, using senjutsu, and great taijutsu/defensive skills. Hashirama > Madara. Imagine if the S/A had to fight Hashirama
 

iNotorious

Sage of Six Posts 🔮
Immortal
Joined
Dec 6, 2012
Messages
80,546
Reaction score
4,116
The uchiha wank is real o.0

On topic: Naruto plot armor -> All madara stolen powers

#MangaPhux!
 

Hipster Madara

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 13, 2010
Messages
16,212
Reaction score
1,556
The only thing I see happening is Madara is showing off some of Hashiramas techniques. Healing himself, using senjutsu, and great taijutsu/defensive skills. Hashirama > Madara. Imagine if the S/A had to fight Hashirama

If Hashirama went evil that would be SOOO awesome. @_@
 

Flawž

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
12,247
Reaction score
1,407
He got a lucky shot 4 times which were clearly at different times (coming in at different directions)....I don't buy that at all. :|

I'm not saying that the winner can be determined, because Hashirama isn't at full. But I'm saying that Madara could have tried harder and used more of his jutsus/advantages during the fight. It clearly wasn't a full fight as their last one took 1 night and this one was barely 2 hrs so stop using this as proof that Madara < Hashirama. That is simply speculation on your part.

Let me remind you hipster, When debating try using manga scans, not Speculating about situations we have no knowledge of.

SO madara wasn't trying when he was backed into a corner? Obito was defeated and was about to die, alliance was closing in on him and he was going easy on hashirama? Lol

Thats ridiculous.

It's been proven many many times that hashirama > madara. even madara himself stated that.

Hashirama isn't even at full power and was able to stop madara before he had to use external help.
 

Joker

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 25, 2013
Messages
29,426
Reaction score
1,559
Let me remind you hipster, When debating try using manga scans, not Speculating about situations we have no knowledge of.

SO madara wasn't trying when he was backed into a corner? Obito was defeated and was about to die, alliance was closing in on him and he was going easy on hashirama? Lol

Thats ridiculous.

It's been proven many many times that hashirama > madara. even madara himself stated that.

Hashirama isn't even at full power and was able to stop madara before he had to use external help.

Orochimaru-Sama solos both neg diff. Even if Madara doesn't have eyes, he still can't bask in the presence of the worlds finest weave, GG.
 

Troyg39

Anbu Operative 🎭
Veteran
Joined
Dec 11, 2010
Messages
3,369
Reaction score
561
speculation. We don't know what happened in that part of the fight. For all we know madara got a lucky shot and got the rods in madara's back when hashirama finally caught him with the wood dragon and immobilized him.

What we know is that in both instances, madara was movement restricted and was unable to move.

I see you are a big fan of the word speculation but you are misusing it in this instance.

What I am saying to you, and what I assume Hipster Madara was saying, is not speculation. It is a manga fact that the rods were placed in Hashirama's back before Madara was bound. We know this for a fact because when Kishi first shows us a bound Madara, the rods are clearly in Hashirama's back. The very instance at which the rods enter the back is when Madara's chance to control him became available.

Now as far as why Madara didn't control him right away; yes that is speculation. Hipster Madara has already said that twice, and I myself never brought that into the conversation. I'm simply letting you know that your statement "Madara didn't control him because he was immobilized" is false because the rods were in Hashirama's back before Madara was ever bound. Again, that is not speculation. Hashirama became open for control the moment those rods entered his body.

Maybe Madara stuck the rods in his back but then Hashirama blitzed him, keeping him from having enough time to control Hashirama. Maybe Madara just decided to wait to control him. Maybe Madara got the rods in him only seconds before he got caught in the wood dragon. That is speculation, and it is also not a point I'm making to you. The point is that Madara's position to control him came first. Whether or not Hashirama allowed him the time to do so or Madara decided against it right away is a another argument altogether. One I don't care enough to speculate on.

Basically, no one knows what the reason is to why Madara didn't control him. But we do not it's not because he was immobilized, because again, Hashirama was open to control before Madara was ever immobilized.
 
Last edited:

Hipster Madara

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Mar 13, 2010
Messages
16,212
Reaction score
1,556
Let me remind you hipster, When debating try using manga scans, not Speculating about situations we have no knowledge of.

SO madara wasn't trying when he was backed into a corner? Obito was defeated and was about to die, alliance was closing in on him and he was going easy on hashirama? Lol

Thats ridiculous.

It's been proven many many times that hashirama > madara. even madara himself stated that.

Hashirama isn't even at full power and was able to stop madara before he had to use external help.
You have to speculate when a majority of the battle was off panel.

He also didn't try when Obito became the Juubi jinchuuriki basically at all. Its probably a plot contrivance.

Either way, like I said, everything is speculation (Madara was able to break the seal perfectly well when he was alive which has shown to have no advantage to the edo tensei body other than hype thus far among all the off panel stuff we already went over with the rods) and I'm done with this thread. I have to study for a test.
 

KingHashirama

Legendary Shinobi 🐸
Supreme
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
27,280
Reaction score
1,690
I doubt he has Hashirama's full powered Sage Mode, since he obtained it from a weakened out Hashirama. Not only that he himself said the sage mode isn't that powerful. While we know Hashirama's Sage Mode is freaking powerful.

Hashirama immobilized an Edo Madara with Rinnegan/Mokuton/EMS.. I doubt the current one is even on that level. People who are making the excuses for Madara with the whole "he wasn't trying" uh no.

Fact: God tree went after the people with huge amounts of chakra.
Fact: Hashirama has huge amounts of chakra (on par or higher than Naruto's).. So he had already gotten his chakra taken away, while fighting Madara. Though can't say the same for Madara.


In the end as I said , the only way Living Madara would be a good attempt is to make Hashirama useless somehow.. and that is what happened. However, if you guys believe that Hashirama being useless = him being inferior to Madara.. then you seriously misguided.. because Hashirama pulls out a move that will finish of Madara with the last of Hashirama's power, will you guys then say current weakened Hashirama > Full powered Madara?? no.

In the end Madara hasn't beaten Hashirama in a fight period.. Hence Hashirama still stays the stronger one.

No matter what Madara does Hashirama will be a step ahead. Hell he already knew who Madara was going to go after.



PS: Not bashing Madara here, because now its clearly shown that Sasuke and Naruto still have a whole lot to do before they can catch up to Madara and Hashirama. He still the strongest after Hashirama. Plus, dude is a freaking genius for having Zetsu stay with Obito the entire time. He used Zetsu with the perfect timing.

You have to speculate when a majority of the battle was off panel.

He also didn't try when Obito became the Juubi jinchuuriki basically at all. Its probably a plot contrivance.

Either way, like I said, everything is speculation (Madara was able to break the seal perfectly well when he was alive which has shown to have no advantage to the edo tensei body other than hype thus far among all the off panel stuff we already went over with the rods) and I'm done with this thread. I have to study for a test.
If he didn't want to try, there was no need for PS. If he didn't want to try there was no need to go chase Hashirama to stab with black rods. The fact is he was trying. However him losing and being immobilized was meaningless because he already had black zetsu to bail him out with Obito..
I see you are a big fan of the word speculation but you are misusing it in this instance.

What I am saying to you, and what I assume Hipster Madara was saying, is not speculation. It is a manga fact that the rods were placed in Hashirama's back before Madara was bound. We know this for a fact because when Kishi first shows us a bound Madara, the rods are clearly in Hashirama's back. The very instance at which the rods enter the back is when Madara's chance to control him became available.

Now as far as why Madara didn't control him right away; yes that is speculation. Hipster Madara has already said that twice, and I myself never brought that into the conversation. I'm simply letting you know that your statement "Madara didn't control him because he was immobilized" is false because the rods were in Hashirama's back before Madara was ever bound. Again, that is not speculation. Hashirama became open for control the moment those rods entered his body.

Maybe Madara stuck the rods in his back but then Hashirama blitzed him, keeping him from having enough time to control Hashirama. Maybe Madara just decided to wait to control him. Maybe Madara got the rods in him only seconds before he got caught in the wood dragon. That is speculation, and it is also not a point I'm making to you. The point is that Madara's position to control him came first. Whether or not Hashirama allowed him the time to do so or Madara decided against it right away is a another argument altogether. One I don't care enough to speculate on.

Basically, no one knows what the reason is to why Madara didn't control him. But we do not it's not because he was immobilized, because again, Hashirama was open to control before Madara was ever immobilized.
To control someone with the rods, you have to be in a more powerful state than the person you are trying to control. Madara wanted to control Hashirama, so the speculation of "He didn't try" is already nulified when he now with all his chakra back and at full power restrained a weakened Hashirama.

Before he couldn't restrain him because he wasn't stronger than Hashirama. Just like Nagato couldn't do anything to Naruto with the rods when the kyuubi's chakra came into play.
 
Last edited:

iNotorious

Sage of Six Posts 🔮
Immortal
Joined
Dec 6, 2012
Messages
80,546
Reaction score
4,116
Oh oh it began! My boy king is going ham!
 

Multiply

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Apr 15, 2012
Messages
12,839
Reaction score
1,034
The king has entered the thread. Admit inferiority or be destroyed by the best debator.
 

Flawž

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
12,247
Reaction score
1,407
I see you are a big fan of the word speculation but you are misusing it in this instance.

What I am saying to you, and what I assume Hipster Madara was saying, is not speculation. It is a manga fact that the rods were placed in Hashirama's back before Madara was bound. We know this for a fact because when Kishi first shows us a bound Madara, the rods are clearly in Hashirama's back. The very instance at which the rods enter the back is when Madara's chance to control him became available.

Now as far as why Madara didn't control him right away; yes that is speculation. Hipster Madara has already said that twice, and I myself never brought that into the conversation. I'm simply letting you know that your statement "Madara didn't control him because he was immobilized" is false because the rods were in Hashirama's back before Madara was ever bound. Again, that is not speculation. Hashirama became open for control the moment those rods entered his body.

Maybe Madara stuck the rods in his back but then Hashirama blitzed him, keeping him from having enough time to control Hashirama. Maybe Madara just decided to wait to control him. Maybe Madara got the rods in him only seconds before he got caught in the wood dragon. That is speculation, and it is also not a point I'm making to you. The point is that Madara's gained the position to control him came first. Whether or not Hashirama allowed him the time to do so or Madara decided against it right away is a another argument altogether. One I don't care enough to speculate on.

Basically, no one knows what the reason is to why Madara didn't control him. But we do not it's not because he was immobilized, because again, Hashirama was open to control before Madara was ever immobilized.

I agree somewhat.

Yes madara placed the rods in hashirama's back, but the fact that he didn't control hashirama proved that He couldn't. Madara knew that obito was defeated and if he waited any longer, he could of lost his chance at escaping the torri seal.

What im saying is that because madara didn't control hashirama, I beliieve that it's because he couldn't. Reason why was because he knew he was getting backed into a corner and if he waited any longer, he would of lost.

-Obito was defeated
-alliance was going to focus on him mainly
-add the edo hokage's and hashirama as well
-naruto, sasuke and kakashi

Madara knew he had to act fast, Saying he was going easy is purely speculation.
 

Multiply

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Apr 15, 2012
Messages
12,839
Reaction score
1,034

I agree somewhat.

Yes madara placed the rods in hashirama's back, but the fact that he didn't control hashirama proved that He couldn't. Madara knew that obito was defeated and if he waited any longer, he could of lost his chance at escaping the torri seal.

What im saying is that because madara didn't control hashirama, I beliieve that it's because he couldn't. Reason why was because he knew he was getting backed into a corner and if he waited any longer, he would of lost.

-Obito was defeated
-alliance was going to focus on him mainly
-add the edo hokage's and hashirama as well
-naruto, sasuke and kakashi

Madara knew he had to act fast, Saying he was going easy is purely speculation.

Flawz is serious? Go head boy, do your thing. I ain't mad at cha U_U

You must be registered for see images
 

Flawž

Kage in the Making 👑
Legendary
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
12,247
Reaction score
1,407
Flawz is serious? Go head boy, do your thing. I ain't mad at cha U_U

You must be registered for see images

Well with the recent manga chapter, Madara fans are going crazy. Someone has to put em in their place. Lol

You have to speculate when a majority of the battle was off panel.

He also didn't try when Obito became the Juubi jinchuuriki basically at all. Its probably a plot contrivance.

Either way, like I said, everything is speculation (Madara was able to break the seal perfectly well when he was alive which has shown to have no advantage to the edo tensei body other than hype thus far among all the off panel stuff we already went over with the rods) and I'm done with this thread. I have to study for a test.


Im not speculating in any way because i have proof that he was immoblized,

You must be registered for see images


----

You must be registered for see images



----

Your speculating off panel.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top