[Discussion] roger crew >>>> whitebeard

[the nine tails]

i know almost all of you know that roger crew was way stronger than whitebeard crew and by whitebeard crew i mean marco , vista , jozu and so on

witch lead me to think that roger was on a hole Different level than whitebeard !!! and why ??


1- his first mate dark night !! now we didn't see him fight back on roger ship but we did see him hold his ground against an admiral !!! not to mention he was quite old and out of shape and hadn't had a fight in years based on what he said !!

2- shanks !!! he was a young teen on roger's ship yet he became one fine yonko who is great with sword and have a strong haki !!

i know i don't have alot of proofs but after all its my own opinion

ps:sorry for my bad english ^_^

 

[The Big Boss]

roger had no devil fruit

rayleigh had no devil fruit

shanks had no devil fruit

 

[BazzBee]

I'm still hoping we soon get to see some of Roger and his crews feats so we can say this hopefully.

 

[Rokudaime Hokage Naruto]

You are likely correct. Rayleigh toyed with Kizaru in his old age, while Marco at his prime is slightly weaker than the admirals. While the difference is not as large as you say, there is still a significant difference.

However Roger's crew is most likely a much smaller crew than Whitebeard. Whitebeard had 1500 crewmembers, while we don't know how many Roger had, considering the fact that they only had one ship which was dwarfed by shiki's fleet, we can assume it was not as large as Whitebeard's crew.

 

[Olorin]

Rayleigh the Dark King*

also ... Roger had Buggy, a KID Buggy -.-

not meant as a serious answer just wanted to correct the Rayleigh stuff

 

[Aertes]

Well, he was the pirate king...I think it's obvious he was on a different level.

 

[UchihaNagashi]

Of course they are.

Gol D. Roger wasn't a PK for nothing.

But I doubt they were stronger when kids. They had devil fruits then but GDR's crew had none (except Buggy).

 

[the nine tails]

You are likely correct. Rayleigh toyed with Kizaru in his old age, while Marco at his prime is slightly weaker than the admirals. While the difference is not as large as you say, there is still a significant difference.

However Roger's crew is most likely a much smaller crew than Whitebeard. Whitebeard had 1500 crewmembers, while we don't know how many Roger had, considering the fact that they only had one ship which was dwarfed by shiki's fleet, we can assume it was not as large as Whitebeard's crew.

your right

I'm still hoping we soon get to see some of Roger and his crews feats so we can say this hopefully.

i hope ^__^

Rayleigh the Dark King*

also ... Roger had Buggy, a KID Buggy -.-

not meant as a serious answer just wanted to correct the Rayleigh stuff

lol thanks ^_^

Well, he was the pirate king...I think it's obvious he was on a different level.

well i guess your right =D

 

[Avinash012]

WB crew had alot of strong people and we have no info on Roger crew exept Roger,Dark king,shanks and baggy so it is safe to say that WB crew > Roger's


Based on Hype Roger crew > WB

 

[Dr Strangelove]

I don't think Roger was on a whole different level.
If him and Newgate fought Roger would come out on top, but he would be seriously f*cked up.

 

[Vincent Pryce]

WB crew and Roger crew are pretty close to each other in terms of power. I'd guess that Roger's crew is slightly stronger

 

[KGB Kakuzu]

I'd say Rodger's crew was definitely stronger, but they weren't tiers ahead. Remember that Rodger, Garp, and Whitebeard were probably constantly butting heads (for sure Garp and Rodger).

So while yes they were the strongest crew, it wasn't like their crew absolutely wrecked everyone 100% of the time.


And lol it was mentioned, but it is Dark King Rayleigh

 

[Fireplay]

Roger=Whitebeard

Roger's crew=Quality
Whitebeard's crew=Quantity

 

[24 12 11 to troll]

We don't know how strong Rogers crew was in comparison to The Whitebeard pirates 24 years prior to the current day. For all we know the Whitebeard pirates may have been stronger: but yes I agree the Roger pirates stomp the most recent Whitebeard pirate crew

 

[VongolaX]

Well for starters Rogers crew was filled with swordsmen and the Rogers, Rayleigh, and Gaban were both king of something.

Pirate king

Dark king

Unknown for now

 

[TheHokage]

The Pirate king's crew was stronger.

 

[David1996]

Roger=Whitebeard

Roger's crew=Quality
Whitebeard's crew=Quantity

This.
They are quality even if they don't have DF.

 

[Hexuze]

I don't think Roger was on a whole different level.
If him and Newgate fought Roger would come out on top, but he would be seriously f*cked up.

This and also saying, "Roger isn't PK for nothing" is meaningless as WB had no intentions of becoming one.

 

[Dr Strangelove]

This and also saying, "Roger isn't PK for nothing" is meaningless as WB had no intentions of becoming one.

Maybe he gave up because he didn't have a D.

 

[ziggyZ]

Let me just say this: if the RP's (them and them alone - no allies - no nothing of that sort) rock up to MF (the very time when WB rocked up with his crew and his allies), I'm pretty sure that the RP's would literally destroy MF.