kishimoto stats

[GOD2U]

This thread is for making stats on kishimoto to determine how good of a manga writer/artist he is. It will be scaled up to 5 with 5 being best and 1 being worst. There will be 5 categories:

Spoiler

1. Artistry ( how good he can draw )
2. Storytelling ( rating of story + are plot-holes minimal )
3. Hooking power ( does he hook you. Staying power. )
4. Originality ( is it original or does it inspire other mangas )
5. Appeal ( how much of the audience does it appeal to. )

Now my stats for kishimoto:

Spoiler

Artistry-5
Storytelling-4
Hook- 5
Originality- 2
Appeal-3

Total-19

 

[Calpal]

i would give his originality a 4 nd appeal 5 =D
but otherwise agree

 

[iFlowMotion]

Artistry-4
Storytelling-3
Hook- 5
Originality- 3
Appeal-3

Total-18

 

[Punk Hazard]

Artistry-4
Storytelling-4
Hook-5
Originality-3
Appeal-3

Total-19

 

[Versatile jutsu]

This thread is for making stats on kishimoto to determine how good of a manga writer/artist he is. It will be scaled up to 5 with 5 being best and 1 being worst. There will be 5 categories:

1. Artistry ( how good he can draw )
2. Storytelling ( rating of story + are plot-holes minimal )
3. Hooking power ( does he hook you. Staying power. )
4. Originality ( is it original or does it inspire other mangas )
5. Appeal ( how much of the audience does it appeal to. )

1. artistry-4.5 or 5
2. storytelling-n/a ( hard rate plot before manga end)
3. hooking power-5
4. originality- 4 or 4.5
5. appeal-4

total 18

 

[Smd]

Artistry-5
Storytelling-3
Hook- 3
Originality- 4
Appeal-5

Total-20

 

[Arian]

Imo
5
5
5
5
5
5
5

 

[6thpathsage]

Artistry-5
Storytelling-5 (plot holes are not a sign of bad story, they are sometimes essential)
Hook- 5
Originality- 5
Appeal-5

Total-25

 

[bigfatloser]

my turn

1
1
5
1
1

do people really think naruto is original

 

[Amaterasuice]

Artistry: 4
Storytelling: 4
Hooking power: 5
Originality: 3
Appeal: 4
Total: 20/25

 

[bigfatloser]

Artistry: 4
Storytelling: 4
Hooking power: 5
Originality: 3
Appeal: 4
Total: 25

uhhh bud check those digits

 

[Fireplay]

Artistry-3
Storytelling-4
Hooking power-4
Originality-2
Appeal-4

Total: 17

 

[NineSNS]

Artistry-5
Storytelling-5 It's a great story, not a research paper. A few plot holes in a project of this duration are ok w me.
Hook-5
Originality-4
Appeal- 5 It's not just a shounen manga, but since my personal demographics are way outside the norm, I'll admit this number may be biased.


Total-24

 

[SIR HERDERP PRESIDERP SDO]

1. Artistry 4
2. Storytelling 5
3. Hooking power 4
4. Originality 3
5. Appeal 4

Total 20