[Game] Peaky Blinders Mafia Game Thread #24

Status
Not open for further replies.

xEphemeralx

Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2020
Messages
260
Kin
260💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
:lok::cautious: You can dislike my optimistic playstyle for all I care. I voted for Eph for his hallow response to TSQ. When Soulkiller and TSQ started their argument , TSQ responded with a true Townie frustration tone. Its hard to fake that. Genuine answers for arguments can only be made by a genuine Town. Soulkiller pressed hard TSQ responded. And you see SK unvoted him. I will put SK on my town list for the meantime for his gesture.

Now in Case of Ephemeral instead of listening to TSQ he just replied. I can understand it at the first round of their argument but when he came back his responses are still hallow. Still enticing TSQ who already in a hot seat that time. He didn't do what SK did , he replied to answer but not listening what TSQ was saying because what's the point ? if hes scum he already knew that what TSQ was saying was true.



I need my SHERLOCK skills to unlocked the connection between ANSATSUKEN and XEPH.
I didn't buy tsq's "frustration" schtick as genuine townie frustration

He checked all the boxes for scum that got pissy because they were caught early and throwing a fit/trying to find a quick mislynch

And his eod was the last straw, there's no way to genuinely town read that slot when he played the way he did, which also facilitated my associative read on Michelle in case tsq did indeed flip scum
 

xEphemeralx

Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2020
Messages
260
Kin
260💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I hate when town self sabotages acting erratic I expected better of thestatusquo


The players I'm honing in on this phase are ansat, ephmeral, pk and rej

@Rej You say you dont want to go indepth in reads in fear it will backfire but not doing so will lead to another mislynch on you. Also with your lazy scum hunting I didnt like your flip flopping votes last phase that were influenced by others.

@xEphemeralx your another player with your playstyle that will lead to a mislynch due to your unecessarily confrontational and joking style of play which I dont get from you seriously looking for scum
tsq was the one who kept trying to drag me into confrontation

I was just calling him out on his bullshit and he was getting personal and and insulting the skill level of whoever doubted him

So, come on now lmao

I will admit however that my argument with Michelle at eod was dumb, fwiw
 
  • Angry
Reactions: Just_Red

Premfection

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 5, 2020
Messages
2,069
Kin
1,575💸
Kumi
8,090💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Yea I wasnt sure if it was my inexperience but nothing at all struck me as town from tsq. I figured that people were reading too much into it. I definitely felt that Michelle was town though.
Truth is I could have a reason to distrust anyone here, but there just isnt a whole lot I have to go by. The fact that tsq came out as town especially makes it difficult to distinguish between scum and town posts.

Rej is on my radar rn just going by how he was posting earlier
 

Alice in Noodleland

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
4,917
Kin
5,003💸
Kumi
70💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
There's literally no reason to think tsq was the vigi

The bolded section is essentially your day 1 in a nutshell as well, and that of many others really

And why are you bringing up 3rd parties?

I have a reason to think he was the vigi because at some point he somewhat slipped, the word he used hinting towards a killing role. I brought 3rd parties because


FIRST

I CAN

SECOND

I CAN

THIRD

Were playing a 14 role game..we usually have third parties with this number of players, welcome to AB mafia game.

I didn't buy tsq's "frustration" schtick as genuine townie frustration

He checked all the boxes for scum that got pissy because they were caught early and throwing a fit/trying to find a quick mislynch

And his eod was the last straw, there's no way to genuinely town read that slot when he played the way he did, which also facilitated my associative read on Michelle in case tsq did indeed flip scum

BECAUSE YOU DIDNT LISTENED TO WHAT HE was SAYING.




VOTELYNCH XEPH

Dont worry Dear i will surely change my vote later on..for the meantime i will put you as a bait in my hook. I learned last DP that you're a good bait.
 

xEphemeralx

Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2020
Messages
260
Kin
260💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
I have a reason to think he was the vigi because at some point he somewhat slipped, the word he used hinting towards a killing role. I brought 3rd parties because


FIRST

I CAN

SECOND

I CAN

THIRD

Were playing a 14 role game..we usually have third parties with this number of players, welcome to AB mafia game.




BECAUSE YOU DIDNT LISTENED TO WHAT HE was SAYING.




VOTELYNCH XEPH

Dont worry Dear i will surely change my vote later on..for the meantime i will put you as a bait in my hook. I learned last DP that you're a good bait.
You brought up third parties because you can huh?

Let me give you my take

You're bringing up 3rd parties to derail the thread with pointless discussion, as many scum tend to do in in games with closed rolesets. And it's quite effective too.

If 3rd parties are a thing you guys usually have, then there's all the more reason you should know that discussing 3rd parties is not beneficial at this stage of the game, or ever depending on the circumstances.

And yes, I did listen to what he was saying, which is exactly why I ended up tunneling him as hard as I did.
 

Ansatsuken

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
27,345
Kin
4,798💸
Kumi
649💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Also want to hear everyone's thoughts on the night kill of michelle.
Michelle have few players that she believes to be scum, Rej and Ephemeral.

People that playing mafia always abide by the rule that when a player became a suspect of one player/getting voted by one player and the player who suspecting/voting that player getting night killed people are fast to come with conclusion saying "it doesn't make much sense to think the player who get suspected/voted by the dead player in the previous DP is the one who killed that player"

The mental dilemma suffered by many town players. They unable to think about unexpected possibility.

Town think the kill is to frame the suspect player. Example of situation: Michelle suspecting Rej in the previous DP and Rej killed her at night". Rej defending himself by saying "the Night Kill is someone trying to frame me". So this statement undeniably able to put Townies in doubting state. It playing with their mind. It creates a doubt on the possibility of Rej who killed Best Michelle. The moment of unacceptance of unthinkable possibility in town.

So I believe the one who killed Michelle is her suspect, Rej or Ephemeral.
 

xEphemeralx

Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2020
Messages
260
Kin
260💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Yea I wasnt sure if it was my inexperience but nothing at all struck me as town from tsq. I figured that people were reading too much into it. I definitely felt that Michelle was town though.
Truth is I could have a reason to distrust anyone here, but there just isnt a whole lot I have to go by. The fact that tsq came out as town especially makes it difficult to distinguish between scum and town posts.

Rej is on my radar rn just going by how he was posting earlier
Townie thought process

Who were the people trying to shade Imperfection day one again?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Premfection

xEphemeralx

Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2020
Messages
260
Kin
260💸
Kumi
0💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Michelle have few players that she believes to be scum, Rej and Ephemeral.

People that playing mafia always abide by the rule that when a player became a suspect of one player/getting voted by one player and the player who suspecting/voting that player getting night killed people are fast to come with conclusion saying "it doesn't make much sense to think the player who get suspected/voted by the dead player in the previous DP is the one who killed that player"

The mental dilemma suffered by many town players. They unable to think about unexpected possibility.

Town think the kill is to frame the suspect player. Example of situation: Michelle suspecting Rej in the previous DP and Rej killed her at night". Rej defending himself by saying "the Night Kill is someone trying to frame me". So this statement undeniably able to put Townies in doubting state. It playing with their mind. It creates a doubt on the possibility of Rej who killed Best Michelle. The moment of unacceptance of unthinkable possibility in town.

So I believe the one who killed Michelle is her suspect, Rej or Ephemeral.
Severe wifom alert
 

Ansatsuken

Active member
Supreme
Joined
Jul 23, 2014
Messages
27,345
Kin
4,798💸
Kumi
649💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
I have a reason to think he was the vigi because at some point he somewhat slipped, the word he used hinting towards a killing role. I brought 3rd parties because


FIRST

I CAN

SECOND

I CAN

THIRD

Were playing a 14 role game..we usually have third parties with this number of players, welcome to AB mafia game.




BECAUSE YOU DIDNT LISTENED TO WHAT HE was SAYING.




VOTELYNCH XEPH

Dont worry Dear i will surely change my vote later on..for the meantime i will put you as a bait in my hook. I learned last DP that you're a good bait.
If third party aka Serial Killer is in this game where's the other kill? We only have one kill last night.

Do you think there's odd and even NK? Care to shares your opinion. You seem to 'know' something.
 

Premfection

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 5, 2020
Messages
2,069
Kin
1,575💸
Kumi
8,090💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Eek

I dont have anything to add unfortunately. Hope others add something soon.

-Best- and Mr.Lonely need to show up soon. If they're actually town they might be victims of a mislynch. :' )
 

Premfection

Active member
Veteran
Joined
Feb 5, 2020
Messages
2,069
Kin
1,575💸
Kumi
8,090💴
Trait Points
0⚔️
Awards
Okay I have a new analysis.
Rej is my prime suspect now.
On Page 29, Michelle says that they are their number 1 scum read, but nobody had agreed to lynch them since tsq was more of a prime suspect at the time.
TSQ also defended Rej, but said they "didnt have time to explain" why they were town. So many names were provided as if he just knew something but that would be impossible.
Unfortunately we didnt get much info there in consequence.

On a few occasions, Rej was asked to provide his thoughts and not much was given. They did choose to go after a mid wagon who wasnt posting at all (Best) at first which I would find convenient if they are wolf.

I also feel that with this knowledge we know that it would be convenient to have Michelle killed during the night phase. It could be an easy set up to make everyone suspicious of xEphemeralx also since they were the one to get the wagon going that let to tsq lynched, and if they (eph) were indeed wolf, it would make sense to kill Michelle for coming so close to lynching them.

Hope I provided enough for some debate :w
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top