(PuppyDogGeneral) vs (DrProof): Minato vs Kisame Debate!

[DrProof]

Kisame vs Minato


This will be a debate against DrProof, and PuppyDogGeneral, Kisame will be represented by yours truly (DrProof) while as Minato will be represented by the Legendary PuppyDogGeneral.

Location:
Gaara vs Kimimaro

Intel:
Manga Knowledge

Restrictions:
Reaper Death Seal


Rules

• Manga Proof Only
• Must Not Double-Post
• Do not post, If You Aren't A Judge

PuppyDogGeneral you may have the first move.


Judges

• 1timeonly
• Kuniumi
• N1nken

​

 

[Obito3631]

minato stomps low diff
he summons gamabunta rendering the water dome useless then throws a kunai in front of kisame and slit his throat

 

[DrProof]

minato stomps low diff
he summons gamabunta making the water dome useless then throws a kunai in front of kisame and slit his throat

Cool analysis bro.

 

[Obito3631]

Cool analysis bro.

im trying my best

 

[Penguin]

I will judge.

 

[DrProof]

I will judge.

Please give no bias between Minato nor Kisame. Also, judge this debate on legit counters along with other aspects.

 

[Moss]

Can I judge? I like you both equally

(and the chars too!)

 

[DrProof]

I would like to judge. I hold no bias towards either party involved in the debate, be they characters or debaters.

Can I judge? I like you both equally

(and the chars too!)

You guys are appointed judges. Please show no bias.

 

[Filo]

minato stomps low diff
he summons gamabunta rendering the water dome useless then throws a kunai in front of kisame and slit his throat

manga facts is the name of the game goodluck to both debaters I will be waiting in our thread Dr. Proof

 

[Moss]

You guys are appointed judges. Please show no bias.

I will definitely not.

 

[Waltz]

I think Shiki Fujin should be a restriction

 

[DrProof]

I think Shiki Fujin should be a restriction

Very well. Added the restriction to RDS.

 

[Moss]

Kisame vs Minato


This will be a debate against DrProof, and PuppyDogGeneral, Kisame will be represented by yours truly (DrProof) while as Minato will be represented by the Legendary PuppyDogGeneral.

Location:
Gaara vs Kimimaro

Intel:
Manga Knowledge

Restrictions:
Reaper Death Seal


Rules

• Manga Proof Only
• Must Not Double-Post
• Do not post, If You Aren't A Judge

PuppyDogGeneral you may have the first move.


Judges

• 1timeonly
• Kuniumi
• N1nken

​

Who is "1timeonly?" I don't see him on the thread.

I propose a time limit. Guidelines are taken from 6 Paths's comment on your previous Versus Thread:

Thoughts from the other judges? PDG/Proof? Agree or Disagree?

Hmm. I don't care for time limits, as it might be inconclusive when the time expires who won. If the majority agrees, then I will too.

 

[DrProof]

I propose a time limit. Guidelines are taken from -6 Paths-'s comment on your previous Versus Thread:



Thoughts from the other judges? PDG/Proof? Agree or Disagree?

I don't mind.

Who is "1timeonly?" I don't see him on the thread.

He's a judge that applied in my previous thread.

 

[Moss]

He's a judge that applied in my previous thread.

Oh, alright then.

 

[Waltz]

I propose a time limit. Guidelines are taken from -6 Paths-'s comment on your previous Versus Thread:

Thoughts from the other judges? PDG/Proof? Agree or Disagree?

Not really necessary as the debate will end when there is no more progression in arguments. But if given, it would be preferred 3days.

 

[Godaime Mizukage]

Are you still taking in judges? I would love to participate.

 

[Moss]

Are you still taking in judges? I would love to participate.

If you read the OP, then you would know.

 

[Godaime Mizukage]

If you read the OP, then you would know.

My mistake, I didn't know that was the final list.

 

[Moss]

My mistake, I didn't know that was the final list.

No worries.


When is Puppy gonna get started already?